Families Who Hate Each Other In Western Art History

This post has been brought to you by A Beautiful Treasure.

Mrs Cyprian Williams and her Two Little Girls 1891 by Philip Wilson Steer 1860-1942

Mummy can’t listen to you just now, my darlings
Mummy is being consumed by regrets

Essie, Ruby and Ferdinand, Children of Asher Wertheimer 1902 by John Singer Sargent 1856-1925

shouldn’t we all be smiling, Mother?
for the portrait?
thats a good idea
why dont you tell me what i have to fucking smile about
and i’ll try to work up the muscles to do it

Mrs Carl Meyer and her Children 1896 by John Singer Sargent 1856-1925

just a little further back, sweethearts
i think we can still see your heads peeking over the chaise longue

family

i just don’t see why everyone has to help push you
surely it would be easier if just one of us pushed you at a time
no
i need everyone in this family
to pull their goddamn weight, old man
so you need to tell your wife to get up
and you two need to join the rest of the team
i want to do that thing where you swing up almost over the top but then you come back down at the last second

mother8

oh for christ’s sake, Daniel
put the bird down
we’ve managed to sit through fourteen family portraits without any bird corpses in them and I don’t think there’s any reason to start now

The Last of England 1864-6 by Ford Madox Brown 1821-1893

don’t say it
all I said w–
I SAID
DON’T SAY IT

Ena and Betty, Daughters of Asher and Mrs Wertheimer 1901 by John Singer Sargent 1856-1925

your arm
what?
it’s squeezing me too tight
sorry?
you’re hurting me
oh am i?
awfully sorry

you’re still doing it
quiet, darling
don’t talk or you’ll ruin the painting

Hearts are Trumps 1872 by Sir John Everett Millais, Bt 1829-1896

no by all means
keep eye-fucking the help
while Anna and I play whist by ourselves

what?
Jesus
keep it in your pantalets, Sylvia

I wasn’t–
just play your hand
portraitists aren’t the help
what?
i mean i wasn’t eye-fucking him to begin with
but even if i was
he isn’t the help
portraitists aren’t the help
well they’re not the Earl of Derbyshire either
think peerage, not steerage before you whip it out

The Order of Release 1746 1852-3 by Sir John Everett Millais, Bt 1829-1896

oh jim
im so glad youre coming home at last
in this condition
itll be so nice to have someone else i have to take care of

family2

you know
it’s so nice to have everyone together for this
all my disappointments gathered into one room

The Child Jesus Going Down with His Parents to Nazareth 1856 by William Charles Thomas Dobson 1817-1898

this is ridiculous
he’s nine years old
blister or no blister he can walk just as well as we can

you’re so hard on him
you’re always so hard on him
you carry him then
coddle him yourself for a change

mother20

what in christ’s heaven is that
is what?
that…whatever manner of cord you have wrapped around Jimeson’s neck
well, you can’t expect me to touch it with my bare hands, Markothy 
I eat with those hands 

mother26

oh i guess
okay
i guess you’re just the one who pours the tea now
i guess we must have all decided on that at some point

mother27

oh, id LIKE to give you this apple
but you wouldnt be able to appreciate it on as many levels as i do

Tags: , ,

89 Comments

  1. lorettalove23 +68

    just in time for the holidays.

    Also reading these through in one sitting whilst trying not to laugh out loud at work always seems like a personal test of strength. That I never win by the way.

  2. thisclimbingbean +113

    Oh, the apple. I was just writing something the other day about how the children eat all the fruit and there is never any for me. And I *love* fruit. I mean, they love it too, but mangoes? Nobody appreciates mangoes like I do. Or cherries. Cherries are my special, special thing and I really don’t think they quite understand how special cherries are. They’re just like, ‘oh cool, cherries,’ and I’m like, ‘THEY ARE WORTH THEIR WEIGHT IN GOLD DAMNIT.’

    (Seriously, cherries are really expensive here).

    1. balefulregards +35

      I feel this way about perfectly ripe peaches. I can’t tell you how many times my child has thrown one down her maw while I thought: “NOOOOOOOOOOOO!”

    2. Bryn (Plus Others) +77

      Oh boy do I know this. I actually *hide* my honeycrisp apples because what is the point of giving the overpriced organic honeycrisp to the toddler? He will take one bite and then throw it on the floor, he can do that with a GALA.

    3. eleventysix +20

      when my sister was a wee toddling thing, i was talking with my mom while holding an apple I’D ALREADY STARTED EATING and the little minion came up and just took a big ol’ bite out of it, while it was dangling from my hand.

      i stopped midword and she just sort of looked at me like “you were holding it at my height, weren’t you?”

    4. Grushenka +1

      Australian?
      i’m away from home this year, but cherries and Bowen mangoes are my favourite thing about this time of year.

  3. GreenGrasses +240

    “Peerage, not steerage” would be a great way to advertise your interests on OK Cupid.

    1. EnchiladaTaco +84

      Between changing my opening line to that, and listing The Toast as “indicative of my personal beliefs”, I can’t wait to see what sort of guys I get attention from on Match.

      1. aquamarinaveen +23

        i approve. my okc profile is only slightly for finding dates; its primary purpose is for me to amuse myself
        (shameless self-promotion time: linky)

  4. alex_geedee +90

    I think this one may be my favourite of all time?

    you know
    it’s so nice to have everyone together for this
    all my disappointments gathered into one room

    1. extrayarn +15

      I like you you really can’t be sure which adult is thinking that. I mean it could be the old woman, but it could equally be the husband or the wife, depending on how you look at it.

    1. mbculver +22

      Haha, I was just thinking, as I scrolled through the paintings, “Nice job, Sargent, making a killing off WASP-y people’s misery and dysfunction.” And, you know, that he was most excellent at painting gorgeous dresses.

        1. Bryn (Plus Others) +4

          I do not know a ton about them, mostly references in other things (Bloomsbury diaries and such), but all three kids grew up to be literary/artistic and they formed their own little coterie. Now I want to go find some biographies to read! But this is a start: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sitwells

  5. winterbymorning +74

    That guy with the bird! Look how smug he is. “Verily, ladies, we shall FEAST tonight, now that I have successfully shot this bird. Aren’t you grateful I’m such a good provider?” Meanwhile the woman in blue is staring longingly at the rifle, trying to figure out if she could grab it and shoot him in the head without staining her beautiful dress with his unworthy blood.

    1. CaroWR +24

      I had a cat like that guy growing up. He was an indoor cat, but he’d weasel his way outdoors when we were letting the dog out and then come back a few hours later and very proudly present us with some dead animal and we’d be like ‘….awesome, Frog. Thanks for killing that chipmunk. Really helpful. Now there’s blood on the porch.’

      1. winterbymorning +31

        I would much prefer a dog standing ON my dress than a dude like that standing anywhere within a 10-mile radius of my dress.

    2. LeastBittern +24

      “Oh good, we’ll get to pick shot out of dinner instead of having some nice potted pork. How wonderful.”

  6. PonyAlong +35

    Christ, Daniel, give the bloody bird to the dog; he obviously needs it more than you. Better yet, give the dog to Jim’s partner, that dog of hers looks gorgeous! (She didn’t want the damn thing in the first place because she knew it would end up dumped in her lap but the dog won her over because, unlike Jim, it was always GRATEFUL and available).

    “…all my disappointments gathered into one room.” DYING!
    “…I eat with those hands.” MORE DYING!

    And “eye-fucking” is just a perfect combination of sweet & salty verbiage and I want to use it immediately.

  7. MsNormaDesmond +144

    “think peerage, not steerage before you whip it out”

    That line legitimately just broke me. It’s perfect. My grandmother translated it as “it’s just as easy to love a rich man as a poor one, bubbaleh.” It’s good to know that the sentiment has remained the same through the ages.

    1. betsymore +46

      My stepmom used to quote her mother as saying the same thing, except with “marry” rather than “love,” and minus “bubbaleh,” because they were WASPs. I enjoyed pointing out that statistically, it was NOT just as easy to marry a rich man as a poor man, but somehow that objection fell on deaf ears.

      1. Phebe +15

        I honestly thought my mom made that saying up and that it was an especially cold thing for her to say. This is a mom saying, then. But a particular type of mom saying. I feel like, with my mom, there are very few examples (few, but not zero) of benign, kindly mom quotes and whole heaps of unknowingly cruel, calculating, passive-agressive quotes. And then fewer (but not zero), out right cruel quotes. This is my mom, anyway.

    1. Unreadaethel +19

      And it’s all identical. I’m not entirely sure why they’re all wearing the same dress.

      1. LeastBittern +53

        I have a spiel.

        About ten years before that painting was made, someone was trying to make synthetic quinine and happened across a reliable, non-fading mauve dye. It was ridiculously popular, probably because before then pale people with cool undertones either wore a lot of white or looked terribly washed out: suddenly they could wear color and look FABULOUS.

        1. aliciafoodycat +4

          They could look fabulous and be interestingly bereaved. Half mourning must have been a challenge before mauveine.

    2. HotDoom +34

      Well, they had to have a place to keep their vast stores of contempt, and their hair isn’t quite big enough for that.

  8. Pongo +8

    I think the 4th painting would not constitute Western art. It is definitely Indian in origin. you know
    it’s so nice to have everyone together for this
    all my disappointments gathered into one room
    This painting is the best visual aid for A Tangled Web by Montgomery, isn’t it?

    1. figwiggin +5

      The rest of your comment confuses me, but I’m inclined to agree with the first part. (Unless it’s a Western piece of art done in Indian style? What do I know about art history.)

  9. jekyllian +13

    omg, THINK PEERAGE NOT STEERAGE / all my disappointments gathered into one room

    also the outfit/hat in that last one!

    this…this might be the best one yet

    1. editorialeyes +9

      I would wear the hell out of that outfit. To family gatherings, to work, to the grocery store.

  10. Unreadaethel +27

    Angry man in #6, WHERE IS YOUR HAND? Also, at first glance, it looks as if he’s strangling her with her scarf. It’s a very complicated picture.

      1. ladyimogen +17

        I was rushing down here to talk about her claw! Do you think she is Death, wearing the mask of a woman, come to escort him across the Styx?

      2. projectbeks +19

        WAIT LOOK – THERE IS ANOTHER HAND!!!! Inside her cloak, it looks like she is holding hands with another tiny hand. AAAAAHHHHHH WHAT IS THIS PAINTING

          1. Teka Lynn +5

            She’s rather awkwardly holding her baby under the shawl. It’s cold and wet, they’re crammed on deck with a bunch of other people heading to Australia, and they don’t have a lot of money. No wonder they look cranky/resigned. They have a looooong trip ahead.

    1. newglasses +12

      I think angry man in #6 has his hand in his coat, a la Napoleon.

      Also, the tea ladies in #13. Isn’t that Caroline Bingley, Lady Catherine, and Mrs. Hurst? Having tea in their bestest frenemy style? (no matter who the actual subjects of the portrait are–)

  11. StillT +31

    Daniel may be obnoxious, waving that bird around and all, but he’s also demonstrating flawless selfie form. If that bird was a camera, he’d have a killer Instagram post.

    1. YoungLeafedJune +65

      Mary: This guy, Joseph. I don’t even. What happened to our sweet little baby? Who is this turd?
      Jesus: I hate you mom! You totally humiliated me in front of Kyle!

    2. Danielle B. +24

      Joseph: do you have something to say to your mother DO YOU.

      Jesus: Mom you know I know that Joseph isn’t my real Dad, right?

      Mary: JESUS, how many times do I have to tell you, it doesn’t matter if you were in Jerusalem, talking with your real Dad, that’s no way for a Savior to act.

      Jesus: *glares*

  12. LeastBittern +68

    The model for the “it’ll be so nice to have someone else i have to take care of” painting is the wife of Ruskin. She remained a virgin throughout her marriage because her husband was scared because her snatch looked different than those of sculptures. I feel like a lot of that comes through in the portrait.

    Like six minutes after this painting was done she ran off with the artist. Probably because the whole sitting, she was like “Uuuuuggghhh, seriously, my HUSBAND.” and he was like “I need you to share those emotions for the next several hours.”

      1. LeastBittern +2

        I blundered over there because the architecture and the clothing is so amazing! But yessssss.

    1. inapartydress +15

      Oh man, poor Effie Gray. Ruskin was also a probable pedophile, btw. He later fell in love with a ten-year-old.

      1. LeastBittern +8

        AND THEN Millais probably schtupped her little sister.

        otoh: eight children with Millais, so PROBABLY the sex was acceptable.

    2. Ali +10

      This comment prompted me to fall into a hour long Wikipedia hole of Pre-Raphaelite/Arts and Crafts relationship drama. Spicy!

  13. lilotelasserie +52

    why dont you tell me what i have to fucking smile about
    and i’ll try to work up the muscles to do it

    This is going to be my new go-to response to catcallers.

  14. Household_Opera +18

    I think little Jimeson is wearing leading strings! A practical solution from the days before strollers, for when you don’t want your toddler tumbling into the giant kitchen fireplace / cow pond / trout stream / steep narrow staircase / what have you.

    1. Teka Lynn +3

      Yeah, I’m sure the leash is attached to a harness on his back, but it sure LOOKS like it’s wrapped around his (non-existent) neck.

  15. tinypaperme +6

    I’m reasonably certain I went to high school with the girl who is squeezing her sister (?) too hard.

  16. redheadedwolf +6

    just a little further back, sweethearts
    i think we can still see your heads peeking over the chaise longue

    Lolololol, that one is especially perfect.

  17. tony

    She wasn’t sure whether it was touching her sister’s nipple or the cold knowon the vvase, but somethin was mmaking Valerie very excited.

  18. Paula Gomes

    I'm on a course and I got the same problem, Better get outta here NOW. I bookmarked it already.