The “Living Burial Ground” at Tamms Prison -The Toast

Skip to the article, or search this site

Home: The Toast

Previously: Cook County Schools, Cook County Jails.

B0124.

Until last year, Illinois operated a $20-million-a-year super maximum security prison (“Supermax”) in the remote southern city of Tamms. There were only two hundred inmates, making it one of the most expensive prisons per capita of any in the country. It was also among the few prisons to practice complete, utter social isolation. Inmates were kept in miniscule chambers with thick metal doors and plexiglass windows through which nearly no sound escaped, over twenty-three hours a day, every day of the year. The mother of one inmate infamously called the facility a “living human burial ground.”

I read about this prison in a Harper’s article. Soon, I began exchanging letters with prisoners, under the guidance of an organization that had been working to get the facility closed for over ten years.

K6521. 

The nation’s other super-maximum prisons include locations in Ohio, California, and Colorado. Most of these are still in operation, and the basic layout and procedures are essentially the same across the board. Inmates were kept in small, broom-closet-sized spaces that consisted of: a bed, sink, toilet, wall, and door with a slot. One wall was angled and cut into the space, creating a restrictive polygon. There was little room to pace. Food was passed through the door. No contact was allowed, period. Occasionally, inmates became violent just to provoke the intervention of staff; being tackled by guards and handcuffed was their only opportunity for human contact, they said in their letters. The rooms were otherwise eerily silent. The building was modeled after Guantánamo.

C7374.

Roughly one half-hour per day was devoted to exercise, in a cage in the courtyard of the prison. This was done in absolute solitude as well. Prisoners were given no coats, and in the winter the wind and snow were often so oppressive that they declined to exercise. Many inmates developed diabetes and heart disease, or at least gained dozens of pounds, despite the often revolting quality of the food (this came up in many of the inmates’ letters; food was spoiled, some men were fed only Jell-O for days).

A8036.

There were therapists on staff, of course. They did not meet with the inmates directly. While the therapists did, in fact, work on the premises, they operated through the prison’s mail system. Prisoners received packets asking about their mental state each day, which they scrawled with ramblings, cries for help, legitimate complains, smiley faces, and their own feces. The therapists received the packets by mail several days later and then sent their replies.

Usually, the inmates were told to pray.

I have seen some of these letters, too. One is a simple half-sheet of paper with a list of ‘feeling words.’ “How are you feeling today?” it asks. “Depressed,” the inmate has written.

The next question is “Why are you feeling that way?” to which the inmate responds, “Because I am in solitary confinement.”

R4812.

The men kept busy by reading and re-reading the Bible, or other books. They paced. Some made artwork using M&M’s moistened with saliva; some befriended the spiders in their cells. They wrote letters thirty pages thick and sent them to every address they knew. The organization I was volunteering for sent them photographs, books, and Christmas cards. When I sent these packages, I used my own return address. For over a year afterward, I received mail from them, on a monthly basis, even from the men I never replied to. It has been two and a half years, and I still get the rare scrap of mail from one of them, and with it a desperate (if implied) plea for contact.

B2709.

I was exchanging letters with a prisoner and he knew I had brown eyes. It jolted me at the time and made me feel watched. He had already recognized my address, as a native Chicagoan, and asked me about the state of nearby landmarks. He’d been locked up for many years and the depth and complexity of his memory was jarring. But guessing my eye color was too much. I wrote him to ask how he knew.

Months later, I realized he thought I was black. It was a not unusual assumption; he was black, as were most of the other inmates, and most of the volunteers who wrote letters to inmates were either family or friends.

B5473. 

Things that men were placed into isolation for: gang activity, sharing a cell with a gang member during a previous incarceration, depression, psychosis, throwing feces, fighting off attackers, complaining about the food, schizophrenia, suicide attempts, threats of violence, listlessness, and gang activity by relatives with whom they had no contact. Most of the inmates’ initial crimes were non-violent.

A6646. 

Some men were kept in their silent not-quite-boxes for five to ten years before being transferred, completing their sentence, or dying. Many died of pneumonia, heart attacks, starvation, malnutrition, suicide, and causes unknown. Families were frequently left in the dark, unable to contact their loved ones for weeks or months before learning they had been transferred or had passed away under strange circumstances. Many inmates were brutalized and starved, or fed only ancient, calcified pudding cups.

N8009. 

I sent them letters and photographs by request. I tried to get them magazine subscriptions. They wanted photos of Mecca, or of their wives. They wanted photographs of the ocean or of happy women with big asses. They requested magazines on chess, boxing, celebrities, sex, car parts, food, and literature. I tried to keep up but it was overwhelming. The requests were often backdated by months or even years.

N4378. 

The push to close Tamms Prison was finally gaining momentum, and the prison guard’s union was pushing back. The Supermax was essentially the only job creator in town, the lifeblood of the community, and its supporters tried to justify its existence by publishing disparaging and frightening information about the crimes of the men housed within it.

I made the mistake of reading about the mens’ crimes. Unlike most of the men in Tamms, who were, in fact non-violent offenders, one guy I read about had done something truly brutal. He’d jacked a car on an overpass; in the car was a young couple. He put a gun to the driver’s head and told the couple to share one last kiss. Then he shot them both.

I stopped writing to inmates after that.

K5728. 

For over a year, their letters sat in a milk crate next to my refrigerator. They smelled like prison, which smelled like the jail where I worked at the time, which smells like teeming hoards of unwashed men and spritzes of dispensary cologne. The letters piled up, too long and too indecipherable, too numerous and too incoherent for me to answer adequately. The pile grew each week until my resolve collapsed under it and I stopped reading. The failure shamed me. I threw them out. The men did not give up for a year, at least. I got a Christmas card from one man this year.

B1429. 

They have been freed, nominally. Tamms has been closed due to statewide budget cuts, and the inmates have been filtered into maximum security prisons and forced to adapt. The mass of violent people around them is overstimulating, and some have had heart attacks from the strain. They are happy to be free, but already a new despair is beginning to creep in.

Many cannot cope. After years of living in small, soundless boxes, they cannot integrate sensory information. They scream when they speak, because they are accustomed to living in soundproofed rooms. They cannot hear or feel textures properly. I have seen some of them enter rooms and run for the very back, take the farthest seat in the farthest corner. Their hands shake. Their eyes dart. These are the men who are the best-off, who have been released. The rest are locked up in Pontiac, Menard, Dixon. All of which are notoriously overcrowded.

N1791. R4812. B7648. K5191. A9248. C6189. 

These are some of their numbers. Each prisoner number has been changed, out of consideration for the innocent and near-innocent. But I have reams and reams more, along with their names, crimes, current locations, and prison addresses. I have the contents of their letters entered into a gigantic Excel spreadsheet with these other data points; long, furious, beautiful, and incoherent streams of prose are crammed into tiny computer cells, from which only a few characters are visible at a time.

Erika D. Price is a social psychologist and writer of essays and short fiction living in Chicago, IL. Her work has appeared in Whiskeypaper, Literary Orphans, Essay Fiesta, The Paper Machete, and the Journal of Social and Experimental Social Psychology, among others. She writes at erikadprice.tumblr.com.

Add a comment

Comments (25)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
this is really heartbreaking and important and i wish i hadn't read it at work.
I remember a couple months back there was a post here along the lines of "what things do we think are normal today that will seem appallingly retrograde in 50 years?" I can't believe I didn't think to bring up our criminal justice system as one of those things. The cognitive dissonance of the people who work in these places must be staggering.
7 replies · active 460 weeks ago
(I mean, the ones who work there and see and participate in all of this stuff, but still think the system works and the punishments are appropriate.)
As I recall reading, Alexander County, where Tamms is located, has the highest unemployment rate of any Illinois county.
That's what I mean by cognitive dissonance: if working in corrections is your only option, you're going to convince yourself you're doing something good (or not doing something bad) even if believing that contracts your actual experience.
Arin: You're right, and Tamms was the lifeblood of the area. When the organization I worked with, Tamms Year Ten, lobbied to have the place closed, the community went absolutely nuts. The state representatives from that part of the state made preserving Tamms their number one mission. It was the only policy issue they cared about. Which makes the whole situation all the more frustrating and sad, really. But that kind of financial desperation can actually prevent any conscious cognitive dissonance from forming...if you're in that dire of circumstances, you don't even question your work.
It's so messed up because this system is based on an idea of rehabilitation - that's the stated end goal. Yet... our treatment of prisoners (I'm in Canada, but things are similar) makes rehabilitation impossible! How are these individuals ever supposed to reintegrate into society when all they've known for years and years is this sort of half-life lived in prison?
This stuff would have seemed retrograde 50 years ago. We've actually lost ground in a lot of areas here in the land of the free.
In my experience, which is limited to three facilities and about a year, that's... I dunno.

Some prison staff know things are a mess inside, admin-wise. Some prison staff don't usually think real highly of prisoners. Some prison staff know they are doing the job because they need a job and don't particularly associate its goodness or badness with that fact. Some prison staff can accept the dehumanizing conditions of prison because they see the prisoners as dehumanized by their own crimes and don't think they are responsible for aiding any re-humanizing. They treat people badly because some people will always treat people badly. They'd harass or demean staff if they managed a Target or ran an office, or were foremen on an assembly line or were senior associates at a law firm.

Some prison staff just don't think about things much at all, because lots of people don't spend a lot of time thinking about things in a critical or meaningful way. Some prison staff are working in jails so they can work on a police force, become a social worker, climb the admin ladder, or other career step. Some people know the system is fucked and that other staff abuse their position and abuse inmates. But they also know they are only one person and you need the job, or you know that you can keep your head down (do your own time!) and maybe be humane or helpful or fair if they remain unnoticed.

People will find ways to reconcile these things or they can't function. You have to be able to dial down the dissonance, so you do.
It's so hard to talk about things like prison reform or prisoners' rights with people because it often immediately devolves into "well maybe they shouldn't have done what they did!". Nobody deserves a box in the ground. We're human fucking beings.
5 replies · active 595 weeks ago
Right. We're human beings, and even if the inmates did something terrible, what does it do to us, as individuals and as a society, to treat them in such a manner as punishment? Also, who could possibly think that this kind of treatment does anything to rehabilitate people? The system we have now doesn't deter crime, it doesn't rehabilitate criminals, costs us vast quantities of money and is inhumane.
Word. Doubling down on violence is not going to solve anything for anyone. Having spent a share of time around felons, I get annoyed when lock em up and throw away the key types assume that my antipathy towards our CJus system is based in ignorance and naivete. No. I know all too well exactly what we are talking about when we talk about who criminals are and what they do. I don't kid myself on that everyone in jail is innocent or misunderstood or screwed by the system and that explains everything.

I do think... we non-convicted of felony persons can't really do anything about the fact that someone has already committed a crime, or be responsible for the fact that they did, in fact, make choices that helped put them where they are. That can be true AND IT CAN STILL BE TRUE that we in contemporary America have a lot to answer for in terms of our C-Jus system. It's not really our place to make felons do or not do something. But it is ALL on us to look at the society that can create the conditions under which prisoners are managed.

It's not okay. It's just not okay. There will probably always be crime; people will always break social rules and be sanctioned for it. But it is not a foregone conclusion that the societal response to those ruptures to social stability have to be dealt with by the prison system we have. It wasn't always like that- not even in the US was it always like this. It doesn't have to continue to be like this.

tl:dr, I wish people would tend their own knitting in matters criminal justice. We have a lot of knitting to tend.
I work with an organization that mails reading materials free of charge to people in women's prisons, and I had this exchange on Saturday with a clerk at the post office. (When I take a bundle of book packages to mail I'm usually at the window for >20 minutes and we get to chatting.) He was pretty resolute in the idea that people ought to make better choices to avoid prison, and that making it less terrible to be incarcerated was a fool's errand because suffering is the point. I have a fair bit of practice responding to that line of argument , but it still makes my chest tighten and my jaw clench to hear people dismiss others' pain with a blithe "that's what you get for fucking up, then!"

I can certainly empathize with the author's reaction to finding out about the crime committed by one of her correspondents- it's definitely challenging to come across that kind of knowledge and stay in contact with the person who's reaching out to you.

I think about the nature of mercy and forgiveness and loss and despair a lot in the context of prison activism and I do not expect to ever sort it out.
Totally. People have their human-rights-blinders on when it comes to prisoners. People mess up and commit crimes for so many complex socially-impacted reasons and then immediately cease to be human in the eyes of much of society.

OR how 'mental illness' and 'bad behaviour' are the same thing in prison.
This, SO MUCH. Even among so-called liberals, there's absolutely no political will for working for prisoner's rights, and it's so heartbreaking. This is how the prison-industrial complex has become what it is today -- it's a huge corporate machine that's fed by public funds and poor, usually black or brown bodies, and it's become this untouchable juggernaut that the middle class is largely shielded from, either because they don't know or they don't care.

Put simply, it's torture, and it's wrong, no matter what the inmate's crime is, just as it was unequivocally wrong for Khalid Sheikh Mohammed to be waterboarded 183 times. There is no justification for torture. We have to better than that, as humans and society. We just have to be.
Erika, another excellent piece! Thank you so much for writing this and sharing it. I am from Chicago and I love it so much but it is essential not to forget how much work needs to be done in Illinois.
I read this over an hour ago, and I still can't formulate a suitable comment. I'm feeling so many things about it, including heartache, despair, and uselessness. Ouch.

It also made me spend my lunch break searching for organizations that connect people to prison pen pals. But I think I'm too much of a chicken to ever actually do it. Also I have a feeling my partner would not approve - not that I need his approval, but my return address is also his return address and I feel like it would be inconsiderate to share that with a stranger (danger?) situation, if that makes sense. Everything is futile.
1 reply · active 595 weeks ago
You could get a post office box. (I'm not trying to guilt you into this, and I can't figure out how to not make my comment read as snarky or impatient - it would be an investment, and not one I would probably be willing to make - I'm just suggesting that if you really want to do it there are probably ways to anonymize your address, and so if suggestions are helpful, then here you go.)
plspassthePinot's avatar

plspassthePinot · 595 weeks ago

Haunting and beautifully written. I'm really curious as to what non violent crimes sent these men to prison initially, my assumption is primarily drug crime? And then sent to solitary due to their behavior while already in prison, correct?
1 reply · active 595 weeks ago
Yes, though the non-violent offenses ranged widely. Men were transferred to Tamms for things as minor as sharing a cell with a gang member in another prison -- in which case they were moved for "protection" from rival gangs. Men with mental illnesses were moved to Tamms for things like throwing feces or behaving erratically (i.e., not for actually harming anyone, just for being difficult to deal with).
Haunting and beautifully written. I am curious as to what initial crimes lead to the men being incarcerated in the first place, my assumption is non violent drug crime? And they were then sent to solitary because of their behavior once already incarcerated, correct?
1 reply · active 595 weeks ago
(I'm just gonna repost my reply to another commenter who asked the same question) : Yes, the non-violent Tamms inmates were mostly drug charges I believe, though the non-violent offenses ranged widely. Men were transferred to Tamms for things as minor as sharing a cell with a gang member in another prison -- in which case they were moved for "protection" from rival gangs. Men with mental illnesses were moved to Tamms for things like throwing feces or behaving erratically (i.e., not for actually harming anyone, just for being difficult to deal with).
Erika, god damn. Thank you for writing these pieces. They are so important.
Thank you so much for your activism, and for this piece, which is beautifully written.

I I live in California, home of another supermax, Pelican Bay, where prisoners spend an average of eight years in the SHU. There is no reason for this. It's inhumane and not cost-effective in the slightest and does nothing for rehabilitation -- it's THE OPPOSITE of rehabilitation. But it DOES make a lot of money for the prison-industrial complex!

Because yeah, building and running prisons creates jobs, as does most government spending. Like building schools. Or fixing our crumbling bridges and roads, or retrofitting old buildings to be energy efficient. But we can't do anything like that, because that's just a step away from godless communism. Why are the only acceptable forms of Keynesianism blowing people up or locking them away?
Beyondwithin's avatar

Beyondwithin · 584 weeks ago

Good article. My father was a victim of the "I-57" killer. I'm glad to hear that you ended your contact with Mr. Brisbon!

Post a new comment

Comments by

Skip to the top of the page, search this site, or read the article again