The Quiet After the Ottawa Shooting -The Toast

Skip to the article, or search this site

Home: The Toast

parliament_hill

The first time I went to Parliament, I was nine, a moon-faced, chubby tourist in a little purple wheelchair. I don’t remember much about that tour, except in flashes: my awe at its baroque grandeur. The theatricality of the whole thing, with the historical characters in costume and rehearsed tours. My dad yelling at security when they wouldn’t let him push my chair up the stairs, for fear it would get the carpets dirty. My kid’s a citizen of this country, he said, probably with more profanity than that. She belongs here.

My love affair with the Hill began that day. I knew somehow that I would be back to work there, but even while I was in Ottawa as a student, I’d go by on the bus and smile just to see it.

*

I finally came back this summer as a journalist, in which capacity I had many more occasions to interact with security. Having no sense of direction, I would often get lost on the way to question period, and they wanted to check my credentials. I would assure them that yes, I did belong there, and yes, I was allowed to sit in scrums. Once we established that, they were uniformly kind to me. Eventually, I came to regard them with the same sort of amused tolerance senior journalists gave to me as an intern. Most of them were earnest kids who just wanted to do well. They made me feel old—I swear some of them look about twelve.

I think of them running through the foyer, looking for bullets, and even weeks after the shooting my heart clenches.

*

The day of the shooting, I missed the whole thing.

As a journalist, there is no more upsetting admission than that. I was doing the job that pays my bills, helping students at the journalism school. As you can imagine, I wasn’t very busy that day, so I had lots of time to refresh Twitter. Over and over again.

Twitter was chaos. There was one shooter, then two, then an unknown number, then back to one. There were lockdowns in place all over downtown, then there weren’t, then the lockdowns were ‘reinstated’ after we thought everything was over. At one point there was supposed to be a shooter at the expensive mall near the Hill, and people panicked.

Other people had different reasons to panic. In the midst of the confusion, I got a phone call from a stressed student wanting to know if her midterm was still on.

I had no idea. I suggested she try emailing her professor, or someone else who might have a clue what was going on. I certainly didn’t; my world no longer made sense.

I hope I managed to be polite. Inside, I was unfairly enraged. How dare you care about this, I thought, when my friends are on lockdown and some maniac is shooting up my favourite place in the world and at least one person is dead? How dare your life go on?

You’ll be relieved to know the midterm was cancelled.

*

In the weeks after, Canada grieved. We here in Ottawa were especially sombre, but people made much of our quiet. Peter Mansbridge, our broadcaster-in-chief, received international attention for his calm coverage of the event. Our Members of Parliament went back to work the next day, and our leaders hugged it out in the House of Commons, an area not known for its hugs. Mostly, it was business as usual.

For a lot of people, that didn’t make sense. Compared to some of the displays of grief from elsewhere in the country, we seemed downright subdued. People told me they thought it was weird, and it didn’t seem like anyone cared.

I was not impressed. I care, I said. Someone had come into my chosen home, assaulted my favourite workplace, and threatened our democracy. Just because I didn’t cry or tweet about the shooting, didn’t mean I didn’t care.

But I think those people fundamentally misunderstand Ottawa.

*

A friend of mine once said that Ottawa is more of a collection of things than a city. I was offended and chalked it up to the Torontonian conviction that the rest of Canada isn’t quite real, but I never got what she meant until I moved to Toronto for a while myself. Toronto is a loud, colourful, boisterous grid with distinct neighbourhoods, a sprawling monolith where everyone gives directions by major intersection.

Ottawa doesn’t work like that. In Ottawa you navigate by landmarks, most of them cultural, like museums or libraries. In many ways it’s like living in a postcard, especially in late October when the fall colours are so vivid your heart breaks and you can’t hold back a gasp to see it.

Ottawa gets a bad rap from a lot of people. It’s boring and unfashionable, the city fun forgot. There is some truth to this: I’ll never forget, for example, sitting on a patio overlooking Sparks St, supposedly a vibrant pedestrian mall, and feeling like we were the only people in the world since we saw virtually no one the whole time we were there.

The truth is that the city exists in the spaces between, in the government offices and the coffee shops that close by 6:00 on Fridays because they know everyone leaves for their cottages. Most people come here because they want to be the government, serve in the government, write about the government, or go to school near the government. People come here because they have a job to do, and the only thing we can do in the aftermath of tragedy is keep going. We do this quietly and with a minimum of fuss.

*

That quiet was on display when I went downtown for the Remembrance Day Ceremony at the National War Memorial, where Cpl. Nathan Cirillo died. Remembrance Day is always an event in Ottawa, but this year it was special, and more fraught with significance than ever. I wouldn’t be surprised if it were the most well-attended ceremony yet. I didn’t get anywhere near the actual memorial. People were lining up near it as early as 8:00 in the morning, the bus driver said. I got to near the end of Sparks St. before the crowd became too much. Noticing my wheelchair, people tried to move aside so I could see, but there were enough of us that their kindness made little difference.

Since I couldn’t see the ceremony, I watched the crowd. There were so many of us: a bespectacled veteran in a blue beret, chest emblazoned with medals and poppies. Students taking pictures on their phones. Men in pinstriped suits. Parents holding babies. A young man in Angry Birds sweatpants. We were all virtually silent, except for one toddler’s happy babble. Even when we were not technically supposed to be silent, we were tentative, our applause a soft smattering like rain, our national anthem barely more than murmured, like we didn’t want to ruin the gravity of the moment.

People murmured sorry to one another as we passed. People say Canadians are naturally apologetic, but it’s really just that sorry means so many things in our dialect. Today sorry meant I see you. I am here. We are here together and we will remember.

*

I’ve joked that you can tell the tourists from the people who work at Parliament not by how they dress but by how they walk. Bureaucrats, members of parliament, staff, and journalists walk quickly and with purpose. No one gets in their way. Tourists stop, sometimes in the middle of the road. They wander and take pictures of all the landmarks. They look at where they are, and you can tell by their excited whispers and glances that they can’t believe how fortunate they are just to be here.

Today, and every day since the shooting, I’ve looked.

Sarah Trick was raised by New Age hippies in a conservative lumber town in western Canada. She lives and writes in Ottawa, where the people are more placid and the trees more colourful.

Add a comment

Comments (34)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Thank you.

(I'm now wishing I'd worn waterproof mascara to work.)
Thank you for this piece.

Ottawa is my town, my hometown, and you've captured it so wonderfully, especially with the postcard analogy. Thank you.
Ottawa rules. This was great.
I know nothing about Canada, and less about Ottawa, and this made me feel I knew it: so beautiful and vivid and moving. Thank you.
Ottawa is so great. We were there for Canada Day in 2011 and there were so many people everywhere, but it still somehow remained pleasant. My aunt works at the justice department near the Hill, and sent some pretty interesting emails while she was in lockdown.

All we, her family based in America, could say was we were sadly familiar with the shock, sorry it was happening to you, Canada, and stay away from the windows.
This is wonderful and lovely. I lived in Ottawa for years and I loved it and I miss it desperately and I'll defend it to anyone, and this is wonderful and touching. I miss it terribly there. I'd move back in a heartbeat.
2 replies · active 542 weeks ago
IF YOU DID THEN WE COULD BE BEST BUDDIES
If you are ever traveling down the 401 between Ottawa and Toronto, stop by my house and we can be best buddies anyhow!
I recently moved to Ottawa from Vancouver and I work from home, so my exposure to the people here has been really limited. I appreciate the quiet of this city, but I'm not sure I appreciated the depth of it until now. I'm excited to look for it -- look into it -- now. I really enjoyed your meditations here.
3 replies · active 542 weeks ago
I went from Victoria to Ottawa for university, and it took me ages to feel at home. Now that I'm back home out west I think about Ottawa a lot, and what my time there meant to me. This beautiful piece really strikes a chord.

Enjoy Ottawa!
Thank you! I felt at home here immediately -- I'm from a much smaller town so I think the quiet really resonates with me. I've been thinking about this piece all day and why so many disparage the quiet in Ottawa -- it's a town at the scale of a city, I think. It's interesting to consider. I can't wait to get to know the area better.

Send you Ottawa-flavoured waves of thought. :)
Welcome to Ottawa! We are a friendly bunch, even if our bars do close early. If you want to explore with people, I'm around. Thanks for your kind words about the piece!
This is really, really lovely. And this observation: "People say Canadians are naturally apologetic, but it’s really just that sorry means so many things in our dialect." is very accurate.
This piece is so, so lovely and somber and just right. I lived in Ottawa for eight years (I'm in Winnipeg now). You're right that Ottawa exists in the spaces between. It does that beautifully and always will.

eta: Also I am crazy about your dad.
1 reply · active 542 weeks ago
My dad is pretty great, not gonna lie.
"People murmured sorry to one another as we passed. People say Canadians are naturally apologetic, but it’s really just that sorry means so many things in our dialect. Today sorry meant I see you. I am here. We are here together and we will remember."

I'm not Canadian, but this made me tear up. What a beautifully written piece--thank you, Sarah.
1 reply · active 542 weeks ago
I am Canadian and I have to say that this is THE BEST explanation of how we use sorry especially the I see you, I am here.

There are tears in my eyes as well.
I left Ottawa two years ago and I still think about going back all the time. It's so hard to reconcile the Ottawa I lived in and the Ottawa where someone could charge up that hill with a rifle -- just so surreal. I'm sure everyone says that about every shooting, but Parliament Hill is such a beautiful, peaceful place. I never went in, but I've been on the grounds a million times. I took visiting friends there, saw the lights show, pushed past on Canada Day. I went there to light a candle for Jack Layton when he died, and I went there to celebrate when we won Olympic hockey gold in 2010. It always felt like a meeting place, and I always got the sense that it made us special, that other places of government were not made for everyone to enjoy. It's so surreal to imagine those events -- like when you're dreaming and you're in your house but it doesn't look like your house?

Anyway, this was wonderful -- thank you.
1 reply · active 542 weeks ago
This is such a great description of Parliament Hill. I've been very infrequently, but it does feel like a space for people, a place to meet and celebrate and mourn and I love that openness.
My in-laws lived in Ottawa for 4 years and my husband and I visited a few times. I have some really lovely memories of your city, including ice skating on the canal and a wonderful hot air balloon ride over downtown on Canada Day. Thanks for sharing this with us.
Patsy-Anne's avatar

Patsy-Anne · 542 weeks ago

I have lived in Ottawa since 1962. I cannot count the number of times I have had to answer the question "Why would you want to live there?" delivered somewhat snidely. I love this city; I have wandered and bicycled over a great deal of it. Ms. Trick captures the essence of Ottawa so beautifully. What a wonderful piece of writing.
This is a really lovely piece. I live in Toronto and have been to Ottawa many times with my parents as a kid for Canada Day celebrations. As a kid and teenager I thought it was hopelessly boring and deeply uncool, but now as an adult I'm starting to get Toronto exhaustion and kind of wish I'd moved to Ottawa for grad school like I initially planned, because it's such a beautiful and peaceful city.

While I don't know anyone who lives in Ottawa currently, the shooting hit me hard because the day before my boyfriend's dad launched this project to broadcast the names of all the WWI veterans who died per year during the war in public places around the world, and at the launch at City Hall here in Toronto I remembered thinking that it was important, but in a historical sense. It's hard for me to articulate this feeling exactly, but my family's not from Canada initially, so I've always struggled feeling to a personal connection to Canadian war memorial stuff, people who died decades before we even got here. The shooting changed that for me. All those WWI vets were multi-generation Canadian born-and-bred, but Nathan Cirillio was Italian-Canadian, like me.This is still something everyone should care about, because Canada is always so worth protecting.
This is really lovely. Thank you.
It's raining on my face.

thank you, this is lovely.
Thank you for this. Thinking of Ottawa from the West.
Well, I'm crying. This is a beautiful tribute to a beautiful city.
Thank you. I love Ottawa and it will always be my fantasy city, even if Monsieur Siniichulok and I are never able to live and work there (Toronto-based immigrants without proper connections even though we have experience working for the U.S. government, etc.). It's a heartbreakingly beautiful and peaceful place and I'm so sorry that such a thing happened there.
This was a lovely post. I have very mixed feelings about living in Ottawa (even though I've been here over 25 years), but I agree very much with it being like living in a postcard (or a collection of tourist's photographs). I live on the edge of downtown, it takes me about 15 minutes to walk to Parliament Hill.

I run along the Canal and part of the loop I make takes me by the war memorial. Longer runs are, in part, along the Ottawa River path below Parliament. I take part in demonstrations on the lawn of Parliament Hill. Heck, I can see the Peace Tower from almost everywhere I go. These places are part of my daily life.

The shooting was a spectacular intrusion into that. My partner and I were both working from home (and stayed here all day, since the radio was saying to stay inside if you could). One of our kids was at a school much closer to what was going on (they had to stay in the classroom they were in when things started until the end of the day). It impacted us only slightly, really, but it nonetheless feels like a violation, that someone should be able to do this (and yet it is the sort of thing impossible to predict or prevent 100% of the time). I cannot help but think how it must be to live in a place where this sort of thing (or much, much worse things) happen with regularity.

Life is back to normal already (which is, I suppose, very Canadian). But it is like there is an aftertaste of uncertainty, fear and siege
"For a lot of people, that didn’t make sense. Compared to some of the displays of grief from elsewhere in the country, we seemed downright subdued. People told me they thought it was weird, and it didn’t seem like anyone cared."

People who weren't here, maybe.

We're a private people, a city of public servants who pride themselves on their discretion. Maybe we each grieved privately and individually, but every single day since, even this very morning, when I go by the War Memorial I see people going up in ones and very occasionally twos to pay their respects. The pile of tributes had grown to massive proportions before it was cleared away in preparation for Remembrance Day.

If nothing else, the sheer depth and magnitude of the moment of silence at the Sens game the following Saturday tells you how much we grieved.

I have a lot of thoughts both as a person who lived through the lockdown and has to go by the scene every day, and a person who cares deeply about Parliament and government, and just generally about the symbolism of everything as a person who has taken one two many Canadian Studies classes.
1 reply · active 542 weeks ago
Actually, I did get that reaction from some people here, but a lot of them were students and newcomers who don't understand that reserve you're discussing. I totally agree with you, and would love to hear more thoughts if you're inclined.
I interned for Parliament and lived in Ottawa when I was in college. I used to walk through Confederation Park and past the War Memorial on my way to the office every day; it couldn't have been a very different route from the one the shooter took to the Hill.

My local hockey team played the Sens a few days after the shooting, and we had a few moment of silence in the arena before the anthems, and I cried a little bit. I'm no longer in Canada, and I'm not Canadian, but the shooting and the aftermath still hit me pretty hard. Thank you for sharing this.
As a fellow Ottawan, thank you. This is beautiful, and I can't really express how deeply this has touched me.
I was in Ottawa the weekend right before the shooting. I have friends there so I go there every year, but this time I was performing, and the event was great and I had been ruminating on how it would be a great place to live. So the shooting hit me extra hard in a totally narcissistic way. Thank you for this piece.
Thank you for writing this. I live in Ottawa and my mother works downtown; I was angry and sad and scared all day, and it's incredibly helpful to me and good to my heart to read thoughtful pieces like this.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Skip to the top of the page, search this site, or read the article again