Link Roundup! -The Toast

Skip to the article, or search this site

Home: The Toast

#FERGUSON


The Indians behind glass:

Late fall is Indian history season, Veronica Pasfield says knowingly. In the run-up to Thanksgiving, public schools always teach kids about Native Americans. In November 2001, Pasfield’s son’s third-grade class in Ann Arbor, Michigan, started a unit about a Great Lakes people called the Potawatomi. They visited the Great Lakes Indians dioramas in what was then called the Exhibit Museum of Natural History in Ann Arbor for their final activity.

Afterward, the boy illustrated the cover of his folder that contained all the worksheets from his unit on the Potawatomi Indians. He drew three deep graves with skeletons at the bottom and tombstones that said “R.I.P.”

“This was devastating to me as a mother,” Pasfield says, “because my son is an enrolled tribal member.” The family belongs to the Bay Mills Indian Community. They are also Anishinabe, a grouping that includes the Potawatomi. “He has been ritualized properly for his age. He has been a participant in ceremony his entire life.” They had taken him to language classes. He had helped build a community canoe. Yet something about seeing the Exhibit Museum’s wall of glassed-in, miniature Great Lakes dioramas made him think of death.


A very sad RIP to Leslie Feinberg:

Leslie Feinberg, who identified as an anti-racist white, working-class, secular Jewish, transgender, lesbian, female, revolutionary communist, died on November 15.

B2qOqPoCIAA_fsn


Julia Wong on “Serial” (no i still haven’t listened i know, but that’s no reason you cannot have your own sprightly disagreements!):

But in the latest episode of Serial, “The Deal with Jay,” my reaction to Koenig and her all-white production team’s attempts to portray non-white subjects tipped from discomfort to distress. The episode provides the series’ first in-depth discussion of Jay, a black friend of Adnan’s on whose testimony the entire case rests. The problem of Jay’s inconsistent but damning testimony has been teased since the beginning of the podcast — Adnan is only innocent if Jay is lying. Koenig’s treatment of Jay provides the ugly counterpoint to her portrayal of Adnan and Hae. In Episode 8, it becomes clear that Koenig is deploying another classic racial trope — that of the “model minority.”


Remember the “Poor Teeth” essay? Here’s a great interview with the author:

Most journalists, I’d wager, don’t have direct experience with poverty but are somewhat aware of their own privilege, and that translates to treating reporting of poverty preciously and yet at a distance—this pity tone, which is just an indirect outlet for their own fears and biases. Do you think you’re telling the untold story because you drove your own car into the ghetto to get some quotes and a few shots of shivering children for a 10-inch write-up on the cost of natural gas and a family who had their heat turned off? If you’d stuck around you might have seen that family build an electric-blanket fort in the middle of the living room, huddle over a game of Monopoly and crack up all night long about how screwed they are. You’re not qualified to pity anyone, and you’re not necessarily envied in the ways that matter most.


Azaria Chamberlain was killed by a dingo and your jokes are not funny and what happened to the Chamberlains IS REALLY FUCKING SAD:

The Chamberlain saga managed to find a niche in American pop culture. It was the case that launched a thousand quips, on shows like “Seinfeld” and “The Simpsons,” and in the 2008 film “Tropic Thunder.” That unfamiliar word, dingo, had something to do with it. So did a 1988 film, “A Cry in the Dark,” in which Meryl Streep resorted to another of her many foreign accents to play Lindy Chamberlain. The mother’s cry, “The dingo’s got my baby,” became a punch line, usually rendered in a mock Australian accent as “The dingo ate my baby.”


Yeah, they know it’s Christmas.


Lauren Bacall’s apartment in The Dakota is for sale. May she haunt it eternally with cigarette smoke and her voice.


WELL, that’s a start!


Add a comment

Comments (149)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Just a heads up if you're at work or wherever that the video in the Azaria Chamberlain link autoplays.
Leslie Feinberg wins for that intro sentence alone. A+.
2 replies · active 541 weeks ago
Oh man, I binge-listened to Serial during my train journey this weekend. I haven't gotten to the episode Julia Carrie Wong is referencing but reading her piece definitely brings into focus some small, heretofore peripheral disquiet I've had about the show and its treatment of race.
1 reply · active 541 weeks ago
The price on that Dakota apartment is 26,000,000....that cannot be right?!?!?!?!?!?!
7 replies · active 541 weeks ago
"Do They Know It's Christmas" is the worst Christmas song ever, followed only by "Christmas Shoes." Why do they feel the need to put it out into the world again???
52 replies · active 541 weeks ago
Off-topic but I'm reeling from a terror attack in Jerusalem that happened today. Praying for peace.
I'm always ambivalent about essays criticising journalists for pitying poor, because on the one hand, yeah, that's true, people can live good and happy lives even in the worst of circumstances, and it's not really on any of us to pity someone else, definitely.

But on the other hand, I think a lot of journalists actually DO know that, and also, "Look, poor people are so happy with their electric blanket fort and their monopoly games" is exactly the argument that shitty people use to justify not raising the minimum wage, not providing TANF assistance, not funding Medicare.

So, like, it's true that life is more than the shitty parts of being poor, but also I think there's some good reasons why it's the shitty parts that people focus on.
5 replies · active 541 weeks ago
Your jokes are not funny, indeed! In another inappropriate reference, Oz's band name in Buffy always leaves me with such a bad taste in my mouth.
Many of the quotes cited in the Serial article are descriptions from other people than Sarah Koenig. And yeah, I get that she has the editorial ability to pick and choose which quotes... but framing Jay as the "thug" seems like a natural progression of how she is telling the story? Jay even calls himself the criminal element of the school- and he says that TO THE COPS.

So now I find myself in the awkward position of having to defend an all-white staff (a thing that is unfortunate) against my white friends emailing me these race articles and asking my perspective since I'm first gen Asian American (yikes). But then again, as shit goes, I'm probably just a whitewashed model minority asshole myself so maybe I'm too far gone?? I'm usually fairly sensitive to this so it's surprising to me that my spidey senses haven't gone off.

ETA: I like the podcast a lot, but it doesn't mean it doesn't have a lot of problems. For example, it's probably a literal nightmare for everyone involved right now (except Mail Ch/Kimp).
26 replies · active 541 weeks ago
I know this isn't the open thread, but my day started off with a fire drill, which involved almost half a hour of standing outside in subzero temperatures and inadequate footwear, and then I got back to my desk to find a job rejection email. You're welcome to join me in my pity party. Bring snacks.
11 replies · active 541 weeks ago
Wow, I had no idea the "Dingoes ate my baby!" thing had a basis in a real-life case. Kind of reminds me of the woman who sued McDonalds when their coffee burned her - she's been mocked and turned into the punchline of frivolous lawsuit rants, but she was actually very badly burned and McDonalds was completely irresponsible. Terrible how frequently and easily victims' stories can be twisted against them.
3 replies · active 541 weeks ago
THIS SONG. For one thing, shoes are about the least practical present you could get for someone who's bedridden. Can't she meet Jesus in a nice hat or something?
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT: THE DECEMBERISTS ARE COMING TO CANADA YESSSS

I didn't get a job I really wanted for totally stupid logistical reasons that aren't my fault and I'm pretty sure my current job is going to be relegated to part-time instead of full-time, so I really shouldn't be spending the money on tickets, but I've been waiting to see them live for ages and goddamn do I need something to look forward to.
1 reply · active 541 weeks ago
Okay, my actual contribution to today's link roundup is this video of a retirement home in Germany that has THERAPY ALPACAS for its residents https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMm4LMF16SY

Imagine hearing a knock at your apartment door so you open it and AN ALPACA TROTS IT SO YOU CAN WATCH TV TOGETHER, that is the world I want to live in!
6 replies · active 541 weeks ago
Please allow me to alleviate everyone's Christmas Song Suffering by offering Bob and Doug McKenzie's "Twelve Days of Christmas" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DTwLqR071M
3 replies · active 541 weeks ago
Can we also talk about the Indians Behind Glass piece? I grew up in a pretty mixed culture, where museums were rare. I have very distinct memories of Native American dioramas and the feelings they left me with on the rare occasions I saw them at museums. In particular, I remember going to the Smithsonian during a rotating exhibit series (each exhibit featured one of the 50 states, and it was my state's turn). The exhibit featured so many weird things that my friends and I felt were not at ALL indicative of what our state was about, and I know I myself felt very much like The Other by the time we left. I think it's great that so many museums are finally getting the hint and are taking down these awful dioramas. I know some institutions are working with tribes (gasp!) to either get artifacts returned to them or at least present things in a way that is respectful of the current tribal members.
Gah, I have so many thoughts about this, especially as someone who not only has Native heritage, but has studied archaeology and has worked in museums. Anyone else have experiences like this??
7 replies · active 541 weeks ago
The "Indians Behind Glass" piece was SO interesting - thanks for posting! If anyone else has an interest in museum studies, or our performances of history, I really recommend Paige Raibmon's "Authentic Indians". It also includes a piece on the living dioramas of the 1893 Chicago World's Fair, which is my favorite World's Fair, and likely everyone's.
sunfastrose's avatar

sunfastrose · 541 weeks ago

This royally pissed me off today - http://pamie.com/2014/11/barbie-fucks-it-up-again... .

The link was posted in a chat room I share with two women I work with. They are part of a team that maintains thousands of machines probably worth in the millions, running a 24/7 graphics heavy service. And never once do they call for a Brian or Steven to help. Well, to be technical, we do have a Steven, but he sure as hell doesn't do all the work for the women on our team.
1 reply · active 541 weeks ago
Nicole, every "Link" post, and I mean EVERY one, has taught me or at least made me aware of the complexities, the joy (and, unfortunately, the evil) that the world can hold. The Native American piece is a perfect example; super informative, well written and now I know how cool/uncool museum dioramas can be in depicting aboriginal cultures.

I just love what your choice of links, is what I'm saying!
Unfortunately, my mother ADORES "Do They Know It's Christmas" (she was in law school when it came out) and last night she cranked it up really loud and started singing along and it was then that I understood the true meaning of Hell.
Gloria Steinem is coming to my campus! My very far away from everywhere campus!!!
Jaime Green wrote a response to Wong's article about Serial, if you want some more spritely debate points! :) "...[If] a student of mine wrote this about Serial, I’d tell them they were mischaracterizing their source. ...In this analysis of a moment from Serial, Wong implies that Koenig doesn’t interrogate these impulses and responses in herself, neither in the immediate vicinity of this moment nor throughout the rest of the podcast. When in fact, as any listener of Serial would know, the exact opposite is true." http://jaimegreen.net/post/102812521331/the-probl...
Wait, the facebook tag is "Come and get your links" and no mention of this? http://variety.com/2014/digital/news/guardians-of...

Post a new comment

Comments by

Skip to the top of the page, search this site, or read the article again