Trains Are Wonderful And People Are Garbage -The Toast

Skip to the article, or search this site

Home: The Toast

train1Come on in and sit down. I wanna talk to you about trains for a minute. It’s fine, you’re not in trouble, I just — no, you know what, yes, you are in trouble, kind of.

Do you remember the first-ever Treehouse of Horror episode on The Simpsons back in Season Two? The one that spoofed the classic Twilight Zone episode “To Serve Man,” where Kang and Kodos abduct the Simpsons and Lisa finds a cookbook called How To Cook Humans and is convinced the Rigellians are going to eat them and then Kang blows dust off the title and it reads How To Cook For Humans and then Lisa blows off more dust and it reads How To Cook Forty Humans and then Kang blows the last of the dust off and it finally reads How To Cook For Forty Humans?

And then Lisa says “Well, why were you trying to make us eat all the time?” and Kang says “Make you eat? We merely provided a sumptuous banquet and frankly you people made pigs out of yourselves” and then Serak the Preparer starts crying and then Kang says “Well, if you wanted to make Serak the Preparer cry, mission accomplished,” and they drop the Simpsons off back at home and tell them, “We offered you paradise. You would have experienced emotions a hundred times greater than what you call love. And a thousand times greater than what you call fun. You would have been treated like gods and lived forever in beauty. But, now, because of your distrustful nature, that can never be.”

Amtrak is Kang, Kodos, and Serak the Preparer all rolled into one, and we are Lisa Simpson. Read on, if you would examine your own soul:

After all the hype and excitement over it new residency program for writers, Amtrak officially announced guidelines for the new program…A closer examination of the program’s official terms has some writers tempering their interest. Specifically, they are balking at the fact that Amtrak wants rights to their submitted writing samples…

Included in the application for the residency program is a required writing sample (no more than 10 pages), to ensure that Amtrak is sending actual serious writers on a residency and not just someone looking for a free ride. After reading the quoted portion of Section 6 above, however, writers are questioning whether or not they cede rights to their submitted samples simply by applying. The fear is, essentially, that Amtrak can do whatever it wants with submitted work, even work that they have been planning to use elsewhere.

train3You have a garbage soul and you look for garbage; you smell for it, you seek it out, you keep your head low to the ground and when you have found garbage — as garbage-seekers invariably do — you congratulate yourself as if you have done something, as if you have accomplished something. It is a free, optional goddamn train ride for a couple of writers, who are a categorically useless type of person, and complaining about it is not allowed.

“Oh, but they’re asking for the rights to republish my work.” I’m sorry. Were you or were you not just afforded the opportunity to be one of a handful of people to BOARD A STEEL BEAST AND RIDE IT ACROSS THE IRON SPINE OF THE GREATEST GODDAMN COUNTRY IN GOD’S ENTIRE GODDAMN SUN-FILLED GREEN EARTH? Are you John Donne? Are you Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, beloved Nigerian author whose third novel has been called “brilliant” by The Guardian for “changing the way [readers] look at the world”? Is anyone publishing your work right now, you pathetic Midas-in-reverse, frantically looking for gold to transmute into something dull and base in a desperate attempt to keep attention away from the fact that you have accomplished nothing with your dead-eyed, miserable life despite the fact that you have more resources and opportunities than every single one of your ancestors could possibly have dreamed of? Were you planning on simultaneously submitting those gems to the New Yorker? No. No one is looking to publish your work or mine, do not blame trains for the fact that you can’t drum interest up in your work of disaffected suburban alienation or that essay about your friend whose dad died one time, you joyless hack.

You have no poetry in your soul and your blood is not the blood of a true American. If Walt Whitman were alive, and if he could see you now, he would vomit tears of betrayal and rage, you fundamentally unloveable clod of dirt. You want a free cross-country train ride and then a hearty handshake and best wishes from Amtrak at the end of it? Oh, they’d own my application materials, my precious application materials. It is a contest. It is an Amtrak promotion. Why on earth would they not want to reserve the right to use your willingly submitted work in their advertisements? Save it for your dream journal if it’s too precious to trade in for filthy lucre, friend.

train5Frankly, if every train in the country suddenly decided that it had the right to all of my work, both published and unpublished, I would thank them for building America and sign the reversion cheerfully. The blood of John Henry and the spirit of Paul Bunyan and my own personal honor would compel me.

I rode a train once; a sleeper up the California coast. We whistled to the towns as we passed by. I slept in a cubby-compartment and rocked back and forth in the belly of the train as we barreled silent and dark past the sea. In the morning I ate breakfast off of a table with a white tablecloth. An old man came into the dining car and saw me looking out the window. He was traveling with his wife, this old man, traveling with his wife around the country after a lifetime of hard work and making do.

“Do you know what you’re seeing right now?” he asked, inclining his grey head to the picture window. “That’s America’s backyard passing by.”

Sweet Christ in the nine heavens, a train is a place where a woman can rest easy of a morning and eat her breakfast off a white tablecloth while watching America’s backyard pass by. Why would you seek to diminish this? What possible satisfaction could you eke from smearing the good name of trains?

train6A train is a steel horse that breathes steam in order to carry gentlemen and gentleladies about the country swiftly and safely — it cannot fall out of the sky, it cannot sink into the sea — and someone wants to put you on one of them for free because you have a five-year-old laptop and one or two aging bylines (I see you; you wrote for VICE or The Atlantic once and then immediately added it to your Twitter bio and then never pitched them again because all you cared about was getting that word next to your name, not becoming a consistent and disciplined practitioner of your goddamn cunting craft).

America’s goddamn backyard, that’s where trains go. Ride on a goddamn choo-choo for goddamn free, that’s what you had the chance to do. And you people took a shit on it.

Don’t be Lisa Simpson. Don’t go looking for that cookbook. (Also, you shouldn’t be simultaneously submitting in the first place; it is not the 1960s. You are not mailing fat manuscripts out to various publishers 3000 miles away; you’re getting auto-rejections within 48 hours, you piece of seething, roiling, superheated trash). If you should get that golden ticket, board that train and don’t look back. I shouldn’t even have to explain that to you.

Add a comment

Comments (177)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
"your goddamn cunting craft"

That's going on the Amtrak website.
1 reply · active 577 weeks ago
I had this narrated to me last night, and I literally lay on my back and closed my eyes and opened my hands and faced the palms to the ceiling so as to allow each word to enter into me with purity and clarity.
2 replies · active 577 weeks ago
Reading your recap of that Treehouse of Horror story made me laugh out loud without even having to see it, and now I'm just sad about the current state of that once great show (which I realize is the worst thing someone could ever type).

Also— Trains are the shit, I always think someone has been murdered aboard and I feel like the fanciest lad whenever I get to ride one.
I love trains more than I hate French-Canadians, which is good, because all Canadian trains are staffed by French-Canadians.

TRAINS ARE THE BEST.

Mallory, you have to read Dick Francis' "The Edge" which is about MURDER and the TRANS-CANADA RAILROAD, and also there are horses on the train, and everyone has such a good time that even the people who [redacted] are grateful for having taken the trip in the first place.
23 replies · active 576 weeks ago
I have a friend who's currently squawking about this on Facebook and it's taking all I can do to not post this on her wall. Oh no, Amtrak wants the rights to the sample you send them for your FREE TRAIN RIDE. Maybe it'll end up in their magazine so they can share who they've given the residencies to. THEN YOU WOULD BE PUBLISHED.
1 reply · active 577 weeks ago
Concurring that trains are the best, and also that this is spectacular.
1 reply · active 577 weeks ago
YA BURNT
BOARD A STEEL BEAST AND RIDE IT ACROSS THE IRON SPINE OF THE GREATEST GODDAMN COUNTRY IN GOD’S ENTIRE GODDAMN SUN-FILLED GREEN EARTH?

This really needs to be Amtrak's new motto. I think, even more than a writer-in-residency, it would make riding the rails America's preferred form of transport again.
This reminds me how much I want to do the Empire Builder line from Chicago to Seattle (via the Great Plains, Glacier National Park, and the Rockies) someday.
7 replies · active 577 weeks ago
I just want to add that literally nothing in the terms of service (which, to emphasize, apply ONLY TO YOUR SUBMISSION MATERIALS, not to whatever work of majestic prose you're actually going to churn out on the train) prevent you from ALSO submitting your 10-page sample to, like, the Paris Review or something. They're just going to publish it in Arrive, their on-train equivalent to an in-flight magazine as well, maybe, and in fact they probably won't. You could also just send them something that was already published in the Paris Review! Oh, wait, you've never had anything published in the Paris Review? Or in "Arrive," for that matter? Hmm.
9 replies · active 577 weeks ago
"you fundamentally unloveable clod of dirt"

Possibly the greatest thing I've read today! You have a new fan.
I was confused by how anyone could love an American train ride, but I think the key must be the sleeper car. I once was in coach for 18 hours on a train that was scheduled for 7. It's different if you can lie down, I assume, and I do love trains in places where the passenger trains don't have to pull over and automatically give all the freight lines right-of-way. As it is, riding Amtrak generally gets me really worked up into a frothy, incontinent fury about the history of monopolies and the legacies of the Gilded Age. GODDAMN YOU RAILWAY BARONS.

That said, your point absolutely stands about people being giant babies about this residency thing.
6 replies · active 577 weeks ago
I have just purchased a USA Railpass, which is obviously awesome because USA is right in the fucking name. I don't know where I'm going (that's a lie, I always go to Minneapolis) but I know that it will be on a train.
I am crying at the beauty, and also from the painful laughs in my stomach region.
The joy I am feeling is a complex kind of joy. It's joy and also bliss and also shame and also an almost jingoistic patriotism, which isn't normally a thing for me, but there it is, like a country song on the 4th of July, but with more fireworks and really excellent pizza.
I love this rant almost as much as I love trains, and there is very little I love as much as trains.

I am a little glad that these people are finding reasons not to apply for this residency, because I don't want garbage people sullying glorious trains.
Julie the T's avatar

Julie the T · 577 weeks ago

I have never been so happy to read something that so completely speaks to my work life, my life-life, and life in general. I work with trains. I ride them for a living, making sure they are safe (yes, actually a real job). Such a testimonial to the glory and magnificence of trains, and the mewling, fetid, corroded soul of humanity, could not have been better conceived by Leland Stanford himself.

Mallory, this is a goddamn masterpiece
7 replies · active 577 weeks ago
trains are miracles. i make the round trip (philly to new york) several times a year to see my family, and trains make traveling through the literal wasteland of newark feel like a journey into the soul.
2 replies · active 576 weeks ago
Oh for fuck's sake, are people really complaining about this? Like, what, you thought Amtrak was going to read your precious writing sample and be blown away by your talent and give you this amazing gift just cause they thought you were awesome, without getting anything out of it themselves? "Oh no, Amtrak owns 10 pages of my novel about white person ennui in New York City, they might actually publish some of it and then I'd have free name recognition and publicity along with a free train ride! How terrible!" Your writing is good enough to get a free train ride (which is goddamn expensive for the rest of us lowly non-writer humans, in case you'd forgotten, exalted word-crafter) but too good to be on the Amtrak website or whatever? Are you actively trying NOT to make a living with this writing thing? Free. Train. Ride. Just stop right there and kiss the earth and praise the heavens for this opportunity. I mean, really.
4 replies · active 577 weeks ago
leapingrabbit's avatar

leapingrabbit · 577 weeks ago

Yes! I'm planning a cross-country trip by train for later this year. Southwest Chief from Chicago to LA, Coast Starlight from LA to San Fran, California Zephyr from San Fran to Chicago, for those interested. I wanted to go visit my brother in California, and I've never been west of Dallas before. I figured this would be a great way to see the country.
2 replies · active 577 weeks ago
Mallory, I strongly recommend visiting Japan (in the event you haven't already), because there are trains crossing every inch of a gorgeous countryside that you can ride for a pittance, and there are trains of every conceivable shape and size, and some (okay, one) of the station masters is an actual housecat with a tiny station master uniform, and it strikes me as a destination for any train lover even if it isn't the Greatest Country on Earth™.
4 replies · active 577 weeks ago
Sometimes when I am on an expensive,over-capacity Northeast Corridor Amtrak delayed on the tracks somewhere between New Haven and Mystic, CT, listening to some dude in a rumpled suit yell at his phone about being late for his Boston meeting, I feel less than enthused about the current state of train travel in the US. Then I flip through the Amtrak magazine in the seatback pocket and see all these cheaper, amazingly beautiful routes that run clear across the country and I realize I gotta GTFO outta New England.

but I agree, people are goddamn whiners and this post is gold.
3 replies · active 577 weeks ago
Ride on a goddamn choo-choo for goddamn free

Please let Amtrak make this the official slogan for this program. Please.
1 reply · active 577 weeks ago
CHOO [FUCKING] CHOO, as my nephew would say. He fully grasps the majesty of trains. I'm taking him to a train museum in a couple of months and, based on how much he lost his shit over a little model train going in a small loop over and over at Christmas, he is really going to freak out. It will be great.
1 reply · active 576 weeks ago
As a writer I almost want to sympathize but then I remember that I sold out so much harder than anything Amtrak is asking of these people. Health benefits, suckers!

Also, if twitter were your only guide, you would think that the most major exploited labor force in America is people with graduate degrees. Get on that train and ask your ticket-taker how he pays the bills.
Comments that appear in the moderation queue which speak disrespectfully of trains are likely to meet with Mallory's spam button, and, in this matter, I shall not stand against her.
7 replies · active 577 weeks ago
You can romanticize trains as much as you want, but Amtrak is no longer the gritty, blue collar builder of America it might once have been. It is actually cheaper to fly than to take Amtrak for most journeys. As awful as Megabus is, that's how the people I know actually travel, because it's literally $150 less than the same trip would be on Amtrak.
4 replies · active 577 weeks ago
Mallory (and the Toast) I choo choo choose you.
packedsuitcase's avatar

packedsuitcase · 577 weeks ago

This is reminding me how much better trains are than all other modes of transportation. You have to do literally no work, you aren't going to fall 35,000 feet from the sky, you can see the shit around you and make sense of it, and you can still fucking drink. What isn't perfect about this?
5 replies · active 577 weeks ago
I got into college based on an essay I wrote about how much I love trains.
1 reply · active 577 weeks ago
Every time I travel by train, I am struck by the dignity and civility it allows passengers. You arrive in a conveniently located station, browse through shops, admire the gorgeous old-time architecture and art that lives in so many of the old stations. Then you step onto a spacious car, find a spare outlet if you'd like (it's free!), and you sit and watch the hidden parts of America roll by. Compare this with the indignities of traveling by air, where you are stripped of all objects deemed unnecessary, made to wait in line after line, and finally packed together elbow-to-knee with hundreds of other people into a bland metal tube that smells like stale farts.
What I'm saying is that I want cheap high-speed rail criss-crossing the United States, and I want it NOW. Pull a fraction of a percent from the Pentagon's budget and build us some Goddamned choo-choos.
1 reply · active 577 weeks ago
I LOVE TRAINS. I have had so many god-awful experiences on my Local Commuter Rail (sup lirr how u doin), and I still love trains.

My only Amtrak experiences have been in the northeast (NYC to Vermont and Montreal to NYC), but one day I'd really like to take a cross-country trip. Hmmm....
2 replies · active 577 weeks ago
Please say that this, this right here, is what you submitted to Amway in application for the position. My respect for the company would rise to unforeseen heights, were it to publish anything of this sort at all.
Here's the other thing about trains. Harry Potter, Hermione, and all the other wizards COULD fly on brooms from London to Hogwarts, or arrive *instantly* via portkey, flu powder, or apparating to Hogsmeade. Do they do that, though? No. THEY RIDE A GODDAMN TRAIN FROM ENGLAND TO SCOTLAND BECAUSE A SLOW-ASS STEAM TRAIN IS STILL MORE MAGICAL THAN TELEPORTATION OR FLYING.
1 reply · active 577 weeks ago
Perhaps it's because I live in the UK, but I wouldn't give, say, 'First' rights to my work. They'd probably cancel it because of leaves on the line, and then someone would tear it up with a knife and puke on it.

Mind you, if it was 'East Coast'... they could have it.; Their first class is GREAT. Actually worth paying for first class!
7 replies · active 577 weeks ago
I get to ride on trains at the end of April anyway, all around Austria and Slovenia, so I will be making the most of that time and writing thinly veiled fiction praising Eurail.
2 replies · active 577 weeks ago
I can't decide whether it would be worth it to anger Mallory Ortberg. On the one hand, one of my favorite writers would be angry with me. But on the other hand, she might write a brutal takedown of everything I've done and said.
Do I get cool points because I took the Amtrak to commute to school every week? 130 miles of reading/sleeping, WITH AN OUTLET TO CHARGE MY PHONE/LAPTOP!!!
Trains are greaaaaaaat. I even say that after commuting on them for a year. The NS trains might not be as glamorous as some, but they take me to the city I work in and I can read (okay, play Marvel Puzzle Fighter) on them in a pretty comfortable chair and look at fields and more fields as I go through Holland.

I also like the trains that go to Germany and France. Basically, I will take a train if it's an option anywhere even if it's twice as long. Do you know you can basically just show up to trains around when they leave, unlike airplanes? Like I went to Paris from Rotterdam on the Thalys and I just showed up after work around 20 minutes before my train and got on it and then I was in Paris and not that god-awful Paris airport either. Magical.
2 replies · active 577 weeks ago
Suddenly 1000% more excited I get the honor of boarding a glorious steel tube in Seattle and riding down our west coast to the land of ports. This is a trip I will treasure and remember dearly.
1 reply · active 577 weeks ago
Trains! Oh, magnificent trains. I can ride on you and read and not get sick (like in a car or bus) and not feel slightly ill the entire time (like in planes). I can look out the window and enjoy the scenery. I just wish you weren't so stupidly expensive in the U.S.
...I would love to be published in Arrive Magazine. (Last year, my boyfriend and I took the Coast Starlight from LA to Seattle because it sounded so awesome, and it was. I love trains.)
oh my god. Is hiring Mallory to yell at me thing we can do? I think The Toast should add it to it's consulting services.
I think my new life motto is "Don't go looking for that cookbook." Don't expect the worst. Don't be ungrateful. etc.
As a Brit I've never understood why Americans generally have so little respect for trains, given that (i) they are in many respects the source of your nation's glory and (ii) taking a train across the US is basically a Greatest Hits of World Geography for all the senses.

My girlfriend and I took a long-distance Amtrak train a few years ago. The staff were on the whole fairly unsettling, we came reasonably close to dying in a derailment (the freight train in front of us flew off the tracks and, as the attendant for some reason thought it would be appropriate to say to us, "It's a good thing we were delayed or that would have been us!"), we were becalmed in rural Montana for 24 hours while they cleared the tracks and so had to become Murder On The Orient Express-level acquainted with all the other passengers while pretending not to notice that the food was slowly running out - and it was still one of the best journeys of my life.
3 replies · active 577 weeks ago
My experience with trains (up and down the west coast several times, and once from LA to Chicago) is that the scenery is damned amazing, but that the train itself is usually very hot, very dirty, and filled with horrible children.

It is very possible that I have no soul.
All the talk about US trains reminds me of the time did the Starlight run from LA all the way up to Vancouver over Christmas. I'd been to Legoland with relatives, and I picked up a couple little lego sets which I assembled during the trip. As I was a 21 year old short haired woman of the butch persuasion playing with lego, I think quite a few of my fellow train patrons wondered what such a young boy was doing on a train all by himself.

Seeing the rockies change as I went further north was so neat. In LA I was swimming outside shortly before Christmas (what is this witchery?) and the mountains are sandy and covered with cactuses. The mountains became more rocky and treed as we went north, up through Oregon where we were delayed several hours by a snowstorm.
There may be plenty to complain about re: American trains vs. the rest of the world, but let me tell you, I took Amtrak from Portland to Seattle for AWP, and it was simply glorious. I left out of a gorgeous turn-of-the-20th-century train station, had leg room and pretty views the whole way, not to mention an outlet right there in my seat (and this was in plain old coach), and then arrived in another, even more gorgeous turn-of-the-20th-century train station. Felt very fancy. Could not be more pleased.
2 replies · active 576 weeks ago
I read this in Sarah Vowell's nasally voice, because she wrote Assassination Vacation and I love that book and I love her nasally voice. The America, man. it bleeds from these words. It pulls a tear birthed of pure patriotic amniotic fluid from my ex-pat, States hating soul.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Skip to the top of the page, search this site, or read the article again