How To Tell If You Are In A Soft Science Fiction Novel -The Toast

Skip to the article, or search this site

Home: The Toast

scifiPreviously: How to tell if you are in a high fantasy novel.

Something has gone terribly wrong with the earth’s orbit, but modern gender roles are still pretty much intact.

Even ray guns cannot destroy man’s oldest and strongest enemy – hubris.

A beautiful woman who represented all that was good and pure in human civilization is horribly killed, and it is at least 45% your fault.

A princess of the warrior caste with gleaming indigo skin longs to understand this Terran concept your people call ‘love.’

Racism no longer exists now that all of humanity has banded together to speak English, vote democratically, adhere to 20th-century American social standards, and battle alien intruders in a thinly veiled metaphor for anti-immigration sentiment.

You live in a world where robots masturbate, for some reason.

The ship’s doctor has a drinking problem.

You’re going to have to go through the asteroid belt you’d hoped to avoid at the beginning of this journey.

Everyone living on your space station has forgotten about the importance of crop rotation.

There are Core people and there are Rim people. Core people wear silver, gender-neutral clothing and love fascism and artificial light. Rim people wear floor-length WWII-era trench coats and love modified libertarianism. These are the only two kinds of people. Plus there’s one ocean planet full of mermaids.

You have discovered/cured/invented something desperately important, but at what cost?

You have come to realize that you are the enemy you have been hunting all along. Your cynical android companion self-destructs after helping you achieve this realization, and upon its almost-human face settles a look that could almost be peace.

You are the real monster.

An artificial intelligence program is intentionally misunderstanding your commands by interpreting them in the most literal way imaginable.

At least one alien species appears to practice an independently-evolved version of Confucianism. You will have sex with at least one of their most important priestesses.

A sinister representative from a mining corporation with a near-total monopoly on whatever the made-up-sounding mineral that powers spaceships is sends you on a simple-sounding mission. What you think is the mission is in fact not the mission at all; your new mission is to figure out the actual mission and to thwart it before it lays eggs.

Your life story mirrors perfectly the legend of Jason and the Argonauts, but your ship travels between the stars, rather than between a chain of Mediterranean islands.

Your lifelong mentor has betrayed you and all of mankind in a shocking twist. He is deeply grieved but utterly without remorse. When you finally have the opportunity to take your revenge, he is so old and near death you find yourself unable to harm him, because he is so unlike the man who once turned you in that he might as well be an entirely different person. Besides, you have less than 45 minutes to restart the sun with nuclear weapons.

The only thing more mysterious than the crystal star your ship is orbiting helplessly is the human condition.

As you lay dying in the red dirt, you wonder whether the robots were truly evil after all. You will never know.

At least one alien species composed only of women has been searching for centuries for the single male who will lead them into a Golden Age. That male is you, and you will have to have sex with their beautiful witch-queen, whose arms are entwined with copper jewelry and whose eyes are the color of sunset.

You tame the most dangerous beast living on an alien planet with a single biome. The locals tried to master the beast for thousands of years, but you nailed it in about a week.

The true meaning of this silent, ancient ziggurat will at last be revealed, if you could just translate the pictograms.

Science has answered many questions in your long and storied life, but it has never answered the question of meaning. Death is the final adventure, and you’re about to take your first step onto the Black Path Between The Stars.

Grateful joke assistance credit to Christian Brown and Connor Goldsmith, who are into hard sci-fi.

Add a comment

Comments (241)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
OMG I am in a soft science fiction novel. BUT AT WHAT COST
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
The 70s were a special, special time.
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
DUNKED SO HARD ON DAN SIMMONS
7 replies · active 532 weeks ago
After watching a beautiful woman perform “How To Tell If You Are In A Jane Austen Novel,” I can't not hear Mallory's voice narrate this in my head.
"A sinister representative from a mining corporation with a near-total monopoly on whatever the made-up-sounding mineral that powers spaceships is sends you on a simple-sounding mission. What you think is the mission is in fact not the mission at all; your new mission is to figure out the actual mission and to thwart it before it lays eggs."

i read this one in the slush pile a LOT.
2 replies · active 532 weeks ago
I came here today to announce, loudly, in lieu of a useful comment, that MY LOVE FOR HARD SF IS PURE AND ABIDING.
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
"Racism no longer exists now that all of humanity has banded together to speak English, vote democratically, adhere to 20th-century American social standards, and battle alien intruders in a thinly veiled metaphor for anti-immigration sentiment."

I like to call this the Holodeck Problem, or We Are a Crew of Beings from Thousands of Planets but Most of Our Cultural Reference Points Are American.
16 replies · active 532 weeks ago
“There’s this bridge between these two planets and thousands of humans travel on it every day, and there’s this robot who does maintenance on the bridge. One day he removes a bolt, the bridge collapses, and everyone dies.”
3 replies · active 532 weeks ago
You are overcome with love for a dark-skinned foreigner and his old-timey religious practice of "peace." You are definitely not in love with his extremely attractive features, nor those of your foil, whom you will murder while naked. In a shower. Hand-to-hand.
2 replies · active 526 weeks ago
Interstellar travel is accomplished by means of the Something Drive or Whoever Effect or Whatnot Gate. The prefix is probably two hyphenated names, one of which is Anglo-Saxon sounding and the other isn't. It was a spectacular discovery by these two researchers that changed human history, but now it's such a part of the fabric of life that nobody you meet ever needs to talk about how it works.
19 replies · active 526 weeks ago
"The ship’s doctor has a drinking problem."

Now that you mention it, I can't remember an instance of Dr. Zoidberg ever taking a drink without vomiting from both his salt water and fresh water stomachs.
Also I always wanted an episode of DS9 where the Universal Translator malfunctioned and nobody could speak to each other anymore, except Sisko, Bashir, and O'Brien, only O'Brien is too busy trying to learn Japanese so he can find out what Keiko is depressed about this time ("Computer, how do you say, 'I know you think you're wasting your academic training as a botanist, but Quark is looking for a part-time busboy' in Japanese?'")
3 replies · active 532 weeks ago
Half the world is Chinese or just vaguely Asian yet all or almost all of the named/ shown characters are white.
15 replies · active 471 weeks ago
lemmycaution's avatar

lemmycaution · 532 weeks ago

the need to better understand the hard/soft science fiction distinction has destroyed my ability to laugh:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_science_fiction
At least one alien species composed only of women has been searching for centuries for the single male who will lead them into a Golden Age. That male is you, and you will have to have sex with their beautiful witch-queen, whose arms are entwined with copper jewelry and whose eyes are the color of sunset.>>

Change 'male' to 'fat white lesbian with great hair' and you've nailed my fantasy life.
9 replies · active 491 weeks ago
The true meaning of this silent, ancient ziggurat will at last be revealed, if you could just translate the pictograms.

The twist: IT'S A LIVER PYRAMID.
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
I didn't know there sci-fi could be catagorized as hard vs. soft.
*runs away*
28 replies · active 532 weeks ago
Magic totally exists, but because we also have spaceships, we call it "psionics" instead. Prophecies work about the same as ever, though. I've spent my life programming our giant, super-advanced computers, but I recently discovered that I have latent psi powers, which I cannot fully control. Through a series of harrowing misadventures, I've found myself stranded on a planet inhabited by superstitious, scantily clad barbarian tribes. Just recently I've been having significant dreams about an unfamiliar, fiercely beautiful witch-queen.
4 replies · active 532 weeks ago
And you've had it with these [Chinese cursing] snakes on this [Chinese cursing] starship!

ETA: response to kilks401's comment about Asian dominance and invisibility.
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
You will know women are exotic because their skin is olive. And their eyes chocolate.
4 replies · active 532 weeks ago
Probably the core people are also all 'creepily' androgynous and somewhat indistinct from one another, losing all their individuality and soul in the search for a more efficient, vaguely effeminate way of living. All the rim people, of course, remember how to be REAL men and REAL women.

I'm not bitter.
Swap in "TV series" for "novel" and these still work perfectly (cough Firefly cough)
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
There are hypnotically glowing panels which you must ABSOLUTELY NOT TOUCH because danger, until there is a bigger danger and so you must square your jaw, mutter "It is time" and touch one.
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
Mallory, you are the wind beneath my (hot sex-crazed Venusian girlfriend's) wings.

So, if soft SF focuses on character and social sciences versus pure physics and tech, and I grew up on Carl Sagan's "Cosmos" show which featured a dandelion-fluff spaceship of the imagination, then it is my destiny to write the work, which becomes a new genre itself, which will be called COWB-- er, DANDELION-FLUFF SCI-FI.

Everybody needs a goal, right?
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
You will have sex with at least one being, robot or otherwise, who does not understand "love" and is simply curious, or in whose society sex is as simple a transaction as a handshake. You will make them understand monogamy.

Your and your planet's financial situation will either not be discussed at all or will be discussed at great length, for many pages.

There will be a Council. They will take up an entire planet and somehow never get anything done.
Any SF: The engineer says a number of complicated words and then solves the problem with percussive maintenance.
9 replies · active 532 weeks ago
The caste system on your home world is gently enforced. You, a lower-caste person, attempt to enroll in the Academy. The enforcement of the caste system becomes less gentle. You persevere and graduate, only to find yourself prevented from accomplishing much of anything. You return to your village and dream of greater things. Your children despise you.
4 replies · active 532 weeks ago
You're in a soft science fiction novel when your spaceship has 1000's of buttons in the cockpit instead of a couple of buttons that say "fly" "shoot gun thing" and "land".
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
Conversation with the spouse:
"So I hear that 50% of children will be born autistic?"
"That is almost certainly not true."
"We'll be a voting bloc!"
"The data is pretty sketchy though..."
"THIS IS THE ONLY WAY WE'LL GET TO A FUTURE WHERE EVERYONE WEARS JUMPSUITS."
5 replies · active 532 weeks ago
Blanche de Shambles's avatar

Blanche de Shambles · 532 weeks ago

Your highly advanced combat spaceship/giant robot must by piloted by humans, and not by infinitely faster, more precise, and less fallible computers. When the time comes to fight actual computers, you are able to match their speed and precision, rather than being immediately reduced to your component elements.

Also, the space armed forces that you have just joined is totally not a thinly-veiled metaphor for fascism...OR IS IT?
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
Yiwoeu thrasx m'nuardle.
____________

APPENDIX

Yiwoeu: pronoun of the fifth-person syntax, used to connote spiritual commonality between the speaker, the listener, and the unity of all life.

Thrasx: to comprehend by viewing a concept's thoughtform resonances in higher dimensions, a skill taught only to members of the Scholar caste.

M'nuardle: the practice of chronosophical immanence, achieved through study of the Ninety-Three Sacred Algorithms, which were revealed by the Golden Ones to your distant ancestors, who are described so vaguely that it seems at first like they may have been sentient dinosaurs, but it later becomes apparent that they were actually domestic housecats.
"Groabh vrka shhznngrw krrzzhnr."

"Nuking it from orbit will never work, Zakhrad, the incubator is protected by quantum phase shields."
Someone's name is Stacker Pentecost and not one person comments on it.
4 replies · active 532 weeks ago
Your beautiful, fragile sister is losing her mind on a space craft/ also you are in love with her but then everyone is losing their mind and it turns out you are all just little tiny sperm driven outward into the stars to fertilize some alien-star-egg planet with your brains and this is the final culmination of humanity. Also you had sex with your beautiful fragile sister when you were kids and are a very unreliable narrator. I love you, Alice B. Sheldon.
2 replies · active 532 weeks ago
Warlike civilizations are capable of retaining feudal societal structures, creating weapons of both specific and mass destruction, and inventing vehicles capable of interstellar space travel but cannot handle advanced medicine.
2 replies · active 532 weeks ago
The events that led you to this moment are a result of you traveling in time to prevent it, even as you are currently creating those events. You're whole life is a glorious, impossible, closed loop.
1 reply · active 524 weeks ago
This is the first one of these to make me think "I don't read enough."
I was very confused at first, because I've only heard of "soft science fiction" as used to differentiate "Real, manly, SF" from that silly SF written by ladies.
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
Definitely want to read the one about Core people and Rim people going to the mermaid planet. Actually I think I just wish there were a Firefly episode about a mermaid planet.
2 replies · active 532 weeks ago
Danielle B.'s avatar

Danielle B. · 532 weeks ago

QUESTION: is Dune considered soft sci-fi because it's all about languages, religions, & warrior-assasain-nuns who are mainly concerned with breeding? Or because it has *another* conflicted male Messiah figure at the center?
6 replies · active 532 weeks ago
I guess I assumed the Star Trek ones: permanent wedgie in the service of sex appeal. I'm hoping technology can solve this.
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
Methods of transport never need routine maintenance despite regularly travelling distances measured in light-years.
How could I forget this classic:

Sci-Fi Writer Attributes Everything Mysterious To 'Quantum Flux'
"ROLLA, MO—A reading of Gabriel Fournier's The Eclipse Of Infinity reveals that the new science-fiction novel makes more than 80 separate references to "quantum flux," a vaguely defined force the author uses to advance the plot, resolve conflict as needed, and account for dozens of glaring inconsistencies.

"...In Fournier's novel, the idea that particles of energy can appear suddenly out of nowhere is used to explain events that might otherwise seem random, such as how a starship achieves light speed despite the total destruction of its engines in battle, why a loyal first officer suddenly decides to spy on behalf of the aliens who murdered his family, and what became of the security captain whose Southern accent was getting annoying to work with."
2 replies · active 532 weeks ago
The Boss's avatar

The Boss · 532 weeks ago

The image is from "Rendez-vous with Rama" a hard science fiction novel.
1 reply · active 531 weeks ago
aaaaand now I need to go reread "The Crystal Star".
Ew, "soft sci-fi"???

Also pretty sure if you give a robot something to masturbate with, they will figure out how to masturbate with it. I'm like 80% certain there is a grad student studying this in Japan.
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago
You are the smartest most mysterious supergenius of your generation and you are driven by some mysteriously undefined source of infinite willpower. Civilizations composed of highly idealized governments seek your new invention. You end up on the lam and after much soul searching, you meet a woman who is completely enthralled by your sheer intellectual prowess that she is willing to give everything up just to advance the plot. You never have sex with her because you are too busy singlehandedly altering the systems of power which govern your planet.

Now tell me if that is Atwood, LeGuin, or Rand
3 replies · active 532 weeks ago
Thanks guys for this hilarious take on every cliche in the history of Sci-fi. Glad I am not it, although I do not think there's anything wrong with sunset colored eyes :-)
I believe it was Steve Grand who once said "though there is no reason a robot should want to masturbate, to be true artificial intelligence it must be allowed to choose for itself."
As far as I can tell, soft SF has women with agency (which WILL be called Mary Sues), while hard SF has technobabble and 97% cis white het 'Murican men. And also a dead woman.
1 reply · active 532 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by

Skip to the top of the page, search this site, or read the article again