Link Roundup! -The Toast

Skip to the article, or search this site

Home: The Toast

Playing hell in Charleston:

The men and women massacred while studying the Bible the other night in the Emanuel A. M. E. Church were, in their own way, raising hell.

That phrase might seem ill conceived or even disrespectful but it can be invoked here to honor their courage and the A. M. E Church’s long tradition of challenging white supremacy. Their private prayer this week was political simply because their mere existence challenged racial power. There is a long contextual history of race violence in America which gives us tools to see this event clearly but even more than that, there is a history that is deeply specific to both place and to that phrase.


Ren Jender emailed me this piece in Toronto Life by Leah McLaren about having been Jian Ghomeshi’s friend, and her take on his behavior:

What’s startling about the allegations against Jian is not that a seemingly law-abiding person is accused of doing terrible things. That happens all the time. It’s the way Jian wove the most cherished and sacred liberal values of Canadian society into an ingenious disguise that he used to hide in plain sight. He was a wolf in organic, fair-trade lamb’s clothing. One woman I spoke to for this story who is now accusing Jian of sexual assault believes his persona was a deliberate cover for his predatory behaviour. She thinks he created and used his personal brand—one that was endorsed by the same network that brought us David Suzuki and The Friendly Giant—to get in touch with women so he could abuse them. She also believes that for him, in his sickness, that dark irony was a turn-on.

Jian used liberalism and feminism the way Roy Cohn used McCarthyism—as a grand screen of moral superiority that hid his deeper, more urgent desires. Did it turn him on to correct his Q staffers for using sexist language like “manning the phone” and then punch women for pleasure in private?


I rarely support boycotts, as they usually wind up hurting the people you wanted to help in the first place, but I am not going to read or link to Reddit again until they shut down /r/coontown, and I encourage you to join me. That fucking thing is going to get someone murdered, if it hasn’t already.


bow down for sam irby:

when i told him i’m a lesbian my boy jay was like, BUT ALL YOU WRITE ABOUT IS DICK. *squints eyes* first of all, patently false. i write about 1 eating snacks 2 hating: new things/going outside/human garbage in general and 3 luxurious face creams. second, i can still absolutely do every single one of these things in between these extensive feelings talks mavis is always trying to have and listening to this dar williams playlist over and over and over while my bra burns. another of my friends was all, “are you worried you’re going to lose your audience?” and really guys, i kind of am? but then i think if i can write “pussyhole motherfucker” 17 times in one post without alienating anybody cool then what’s the fucking problem? i haven’t dated a man in over three years, and before that i was fucking midgets and dudes who work at foot locker and shit, so it’s not like anyone was hanging around here for heartwarming stories of heterosexual love anyway. if you hate it, kick rocks. you won’t be missed. bitches gotta eat bitches out.


Mallory and I are superfans of MEG, the terrible book about the big shark, which is finally getting out of development hell courtesy of…Eli Roth…and you can talk about MEG freely in this space.


Alexander Chee on working for William F. Buckley and his wife Pat. I became mildly obsessed with Pat Buckley after reading their son’s book about his parents, and I think Chee really gets at the complexities of hate and love in this piece.


I thought this meditation on reading as therapy was fascinating!

Bibliotherapy is a very broad term for the ancient practice of encouraging reading for therapeutic effect. The first use of the term is usually dated to a jaunty 1916 article in The Atlantic Monthly, “A Literary Clinic.” In it, the author describes stumbling upon a “bibliopathic institute” run by an acquaintance, Bagster, in the basement of his church, from where he dispenses reading recommendations with healing value. “Bibliotherapy is…a new science,” Bagster explains. “A book may be a stimulant or a sedative or an irritant or a soporific. The point is that it must do something to you, and you ought to know what it is. A book may be of the nature of a soothing syrup or it may be of the nature of a mustard plaster.” To a middle-aged client with “opinions partially ossified,” Bagster gives the following prescription: “You must read more novels. Not pleasant stories that make you forget yourself. They must be searching, drastic, stinging, relentless novels.” (George Bernard Shaw is at the top of the list.) Bagster is finally called away to deal with a patient who has “taken an overdose of war literature,” leaving the author to think about the books that “put new life into us and then set the life pulse strong but slow.”


Did you read the thing about gay Mormon men who oppose same-sex marriage, and are married to women? The writer also talks to gay Mormon men who are married to women and DO support same-sex marriage:

He notes that Danny Caldwell and many of the others in the brief do not refer to themselves as “gay.” They prefer the term same-sex attraction, or SSA. “To them it’s an inclination, but it’s not their identity, it’s not who they are,” unlike their religious identity, he says.

Derek Kitchen, another gay former Mormon I spoke with in Salt Lake City, who is running for city council, says this approach can’t end well. “When your entire personal worth is your standing within the church and where you land in the afterlife…It’s hard to say it’s okay to be gay.” If your strategy is to get your family and friends to accept who you are without really supporting who you are, he adds, paraphrasing gay activist and author Dan Savage, “I would not say that it gets better.”


Add a comment

Comments (141)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
The Jian Ghomeshi article! Oh man, oh man, oh maaaaaan. I hated how pandering it was—Leah McLaren straight-up refuses to name what she was seeing and hearing about, and the whole story becomes about her ambivalence, not about the damage he did. I ended up rage-writing a post about this article on my own blog to deal with it.
9 replies · active 510 weeks ago
Moxy Fruvous' "Bargainville" was the first CD I ever owned. I wish I didn't want to destroy it.
1 reply · active 510 weeks ago
Does anyone else want to become a bibliotherapist now?
5 replies · active 510 weeks ago
gullwing's avatar

gullwing · 510 weeks ago

#soccerthread I highly recommend seeing your country win a World Cup knockout round at home, A+ would do again.

I would also like to thank my dad for leaning into his #PeakDad on Father's Day and insisting that we get to the game an hour and a half early, which was enough time to discover that we left the tickets at home, go back and get them, and not miss kickoff.
3 replies · active 510 weeks ago
Christopher Buckley's "Losing Mum and Pup" was an interesting book.
I read the most outrageous parts out loud to my husband so he could appreciate the amazing ridiculousness of Rich People.

As my mom would say when she didn't want to be unkind, but didn't approve of someone, "she sure is something"
Oh god. Do I want to know what coontown is? (I mean... I know I don't want to know, but should I know?)

That piece on gay Mormon men was a very frustrating read. My thoughts on it are echoed in the author's, "Rights aren’t about feelings, I thought at that moment. They’re about people having the freedom to live the life they want." Caldwell, for all his unusual circumstances, seems to suffer from a very typical male entitlement--he wants the world to acknowledge his union and doesn't care if his ideal of acknowledgement involves trampling others. There's a LOT to unpack about his motivations, too, like the whole "the man I loved rejected me" thing.
5 replies · active 510 weeks ago
I had a dumb, Dickensian childhood and I believe books a) saved my life [look buddy-kid, it ain't always bad] b) taught me how to be a person [spelling out why kids in books got bullied which helped me figure out how to avoid it, all sorts of stuff on manners, modeling bravery and humor.] Books as therapy strikes a chord!

That Buckley piece was really intriguing; I had never heard of Pat Buckley and now wish to know a million things. Also I googled young Christopher Buckley to see if he was all that beautiful.

I did not Google Buckley's tattoo piece, which I have never read, because sometimes you need a break from reading ugly things - see reading therapy above!
*takes resolved breath* I will boycott with you. Because I only look at carefully cultivated niche subs, I usually miss out on the overall grossness that is Reddit but yeah, I'm not down to support a website that supports that.
2 replies · active 510 weeks ago
The Playing Hell article reminded me that education for the oppressed is so often (too often) a form of rebellion and resistance and I can't think about that too much right now because it makes me sick to my stomach.
Re: gay Mormon men who oppose same-sex marriage and are married to women:

Life is a rich, rich, rich tapestry.
11 replies · active 510 weeks ago
Hello, my ducks, I have returned from a lovely long weekend and things are already relatively hell-like in the office, so book therapy sounds like a fucking fantastic idea overall.
1 reply · active 510 weeks ago
Jesus I would be THE BEST bibliotherapist. I AM the best bibliotherapist. Give me a problem and I'll prescribe you a book, I mean it. here is a sample, you can assess my skill level from these (warning: it is very high.)

If your trauma is: a man leaving you suddenly, read: John Fowles, The Collector. alum in book form, it is an astringent AND a flocculator. this book will clarify you.

if your trauma is: long lingering death of a close but difficult relative, read: the complete works of Dorothy Eden and most of Jane Aiken Hodge, especially the ones that are like B-grade Mary Stewarts. I don't recommend the complete works of Mary Stewart because you have already read them -- you see how well I know you.
27 replies · active 509 weeks ago
Megalodon vs William Buckley

C. Megalodon was a largish shark
who cruised the Cenozoic seas
he could have eaten Noah's ark
and swallowed it with careless ease

William Buckley was a pundit
an author and conservative
his wit they say was never blunted
though many found him negative

Imagine now, if you are able
you had to make a choice of one
to sit beside you at a table
perhaps pass you a dinner bun

The shark of course, would simply eat you
he doesn't have good table manners
he'd swallow you, he doesn't chew
a faux pas of the dinner planners

Buckley wouldn't let you talk
he'd interrupt at every word
like a crowing right-wing cock
a living theater of the absurd

So choose wisely dinner guest
a giant shark who'll eat your innards?
or pundit who will leave you stressed -
a simpering snob who'll spoil your dinner.

I think I know who *I* would choose
With Megalodon you couldn't lose.
I've been self-medicating with literature my entire life!
6 replies · active 510 weeks ago
MEG! I have read both MEG and several of its equally terrible sequels. I also highly recommend Shark Attack 3: Megalodon, which inexplicably stars John Barrowman.
7 replies · active 510 weeks ago
MEG! The MEG books were the last I pre-read for my then nine-year-old son before deciding he was old enough to read whatever he wanted without approval. I have no idea what he's reading now, except that I gave him my copy of Strange & Morrell, so I have a maternal nostalgia for that awful Jurassic Shark. We will definitely see the movie(s).
1 reply · active 510 weeks ago
I had no clue that Meg: A Novel of Deep Terror was at five sequels and counting. The Wikipedia synopses get increasingly impressionistic as the series goes along; the one for book four (Hell's Aquarium) opens with

Scarface, Michael Maren's pet Meg, and Angel's last surviving offspring from her first litter, hunting.
2 replies · active 510 weeks ago
I have a problem calling Jian Gomeshi's predatory behavior a "sickness," seeing as how it isn't so much something that happened to him that he has no control over, like the flu or cancer. Instead, he engaged in a deliberate series of manipulations, lies, boundary-testing, and abuse of the women in his life because he liked to and because he could.

Starting to remind me a lot of H*** Schwy***, particularly using lefty ideals as cover for abuse. ::spits::
1 reply · active 510 weeks ago
Reddit wouldn't be such a thing if we all just boycotted it forever. It would die the MySpace death of nobody-goes-there-anymore. Maybe then a place less bound up in white cis male privilege would come along to replace it.
3 replies · active 510 weeks ago
Good morning Toast, I am home sick today because I woke up with a fever and general aches and pains, etc. I feel a bit better now but overall like a wrung-out towel.
Also, ugh, that Ghomeshi article. I read it last week. That email she quotes on the last page, where he goes from talking about how "gutted" he is by his father's death to flirting with her in one sentence.... so, so creepy.

I felt this weird disconnect throughout the piece because McLaren kept talking about how irresistibly charming and charismatic Ghomeshi was, but the interactions she describes having with him are anything but. I can't imagine being a journalist interviewing someone and having him say, “I’m going to this orgy tonight, do you want to come?” and finding that charming instead of repulsive. She writes, The fact that we believed the cuddly, wholesome version of Jian makes the crimes he’s accused of doubly galling but how on earth did she perceive him to be cuddly and wholesome when literally the day they met, he made that orgy "joke"?

I know hindsight is 20/20, but... I don't get it.
there is a lot of MEG + Meg happening here, and every time I get a bit of a jolt like, what did I do? what do you want from me?? I appreciate sharing my name with a giant shark, but I'm still gonna be real confused for the rest of this comments section.
This remembrance essay by Harris Wittels's sister is beautiful and so heartbreaking: https://medium.com/@stephaniewittelswachs/the-new...
2 replies · active 510 weeks ago
People say there's no homosexual agenda but what about our stranglehold on the cater-waiter industry?
1 reply · active 510 weeks ago
My relationship with Reddit is like a bad ex. Every now and then I wander back there because I want to talk with other people about something that interests me, and eventually the microaggressions and intolerance hit critical mass and I finally realize why I'm so upset, and I leave, vowing to never go back.

If I wasn't already mid-vow, being reminded that Reddit fosters shit like /r/coontown would be enough for me to leave. I'm totally in support of this boycott; Reddit gets away with too much disgusting, destructive shit in the name of free speech.
I have nothing to add to the Buckley article except that I saw a documentary about the Buckley/Vidal debates of 1968 (aka that time Buckley called Vidal a "goddamn queer" on live TV) and Gore Vidal was so obnoxious, he actually managed to make Buckley look good by comparison. Which says very little about Buckley's relative value as a person, but a ton about how annoying Vidal was.
1 reply · active 510 weeks ago
If I tried to be a bibliotherapist I'm pretty sure I'd just tell everyone to read I Capture the Castle all the time.
3 replies · active 510 weeks ago
Off-topic, but: how do you deal with experimental fiction? I'm trying to read Clarice Lispector at the moment and mostly it's making me feel stupid.
3 replies · active 510 weeks ago
The ad at the bottom of this page is for the new Jonathan Franzen novel. How to mark ad as offensive?
I just started reading a Dave Eggers novel...does that make me a bad person?
1 reply · active 510 weeks ago
The Buckley article was FASCINATING ... but I did not realize St Vincent's was being converted into luxury condos, and that fact is now eating a rage-y hole in my brain. I mean COME THE FUCK ON.
Wow, that Jian Ghomeshi piece was uh...not very self-aware was it? Me, reading it: "ABUSERABUSERABUSERABUSER" Lady who wrote it. "Oh Jian is so lovable!"

Also that pic of him at her wedding it looks like he is looking riiiiiiight down her dress.
For some reason the I have this one passage in MEG where the female baddie is described as grinding her properly emasculated lover with her pelvic bone seared in my mind grapes.

OT- I now own a house, Holy crap
That bitchesgottaeat post uses the offensive term midget in a pretty hateful way. I'm not about that.
1 reply · active 509 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by

Skip to the top of the page, search this site, or read the article again