Previously in this series (yeah, we’re doing all seven): Ayn Rand’s Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Collectivism.
“Cho Chang,” Harry called from across the hallway, and quickly closed the distance between them, like some sort of sexually compelling locomotive. “The Yule Ball is tomorrow. I wish to acquire you for it. Say yes, now, with your mouth, before I cruelly crush it against my own, like some sort of sexual flower.”
“Oh. Harry,” Cho said, “I’m sorry but someone’s already asked me. And well, I’ve, I’ve said I’ll go with him.”
“I refuse to allow you to live in the world of the mediocre,” Harry said, eyes flashing flint and fire. “You are the only acceptable mate for me. I will hold you in my arms in front of our peers at the Yule Ball. Reconcile yourself to your fate, and wear something red or purple.”
“Harry, I’m sorry, but –”
“You’ll wear your hair down,” he said carelessly. “It suits you best that way. I have nothing left to say to you at present. I don’t think I’ll kiss you just yet. Go make whatever feminine preparations you have to make before tomorrow night.”
“I–”
“Your watch is off by fourteen seconds,” he said before turning to leave. “Unless you plan on making imprecision a habit, I suggest you correct it before I see you again.”
***
“Harry,” Hermione called out breathlessly, scurrying to catch up with him, only no one could ever catch up with him, for he walked alone, “I got you a Christmas present. Happy — Happy Christmas, Harry.”
It was a sweater she had knitted herself with the answer to every exam they’d be taking for the rest of the year magically and invisibly sewn into the fabric. Harry tossed it in his book bag.
“I got you a present too,” Harry said. Hermione’s smile widened.
“Really?”
“My present is the truth,” he said. “You don’t look very good in green. I don’t know why you’re always wearing it.”
***
“If you want to know what a man’s like,” Dumbledore said, “take a good look at how he treats his inferiors, not his equals.”
Harry leaned back in his chair. “No man is my equal.”
“Harry,” Dumbledore said sadly, “you must not compare others so harshly against yourself. It is our duty to those weaker than ourselves to–”
“I don’t make comparisons. I never think of myself in relation to anyone else. I just refuse to measure myself as part of anything.”
“Harry–”
“You preach selflessness,” Harry said, “but what you really mean is slavery to the collective.” And with that, Harry awarded himself six O.W.L.s — which was his right as an individual — and Disapparated to Hogsmeade.
“The drinking age is fundamentally oppressive,” he explained to Madame Rosmerta. “Under a truly federalist system, youthful drinking is rightly governed by the laws of common sense and natural consequences. One fire-whiskey, please.”
***
Malfoy flashed his SUPPORT CEDRIC DIGGORY/POTTER STINKS badge from across the table. Ron sneered. “Cedric Diggory,” he said. “Thinks he’s so great. He’s not so great.”
“Jealousy is a quality of the womanish and the poor,” Harry said, without malice, finishing a simple dish of plums. “I suggest you free yourself from it.”
***
The merpeople brandished their spears fiercely. Harry looked around. Ron, Hermione and Gabrielle Delacour drifted lazily through the water, arms bound uselessly behind their backs. Where was Fleur? And where was Krum?
Harry turned to face the merpeople. “The true test is not whether a Triwizard Champion can perform an act of charity — an act of mercy — whether I am capable of saving these victims, these leechers, these children. I can, I assure you. The question is whether I can do without them, whether I can exist solely as my own entity. Whether I can perform an act of accomplishment.”
Harry carefully began placing the heaviest stones he could carry over the rope connecting Ron and Hermione, until they were hopelessly enmeshed in the lake bed.
“The answer, of course,” he said clearly, “is that I can.” He swam away. He swam alone. He had lost the task, perhaps, but he had won the only tournament that truly matters — the tournament of self.
“I hope you’re not expecting me to apologize,” Harry said without looking up the next day when a very muddy and a very angry-looking Ron and Hermione appeared in front of the door to his study. “And don’t come any closer. You’ll track lake water all over my new rug.”
***
“Listen, Harry,” Cedric asked. “The third challenge. Do you have any idea what it’s about? I can’t seem to figure out the last clue for the life of me.”
“If you want my advice, Cedric, you’ve made a mistake already. By asking me. By asking anyone. Never ask people. Not about your work. Don’t you know what you want? How can you stand it, not to know?”
Cedric shook his head. “How do you always manage to decide?”
“How can you let others decide for you?”
“Do you always have to have a purpose? Do you always have to be so damn serious? Can’t you ever do things without reason, just like everybody else? You’re so serious, so old. Everything’s important with you, everything’s great, significant in some way, every minute, even when you keep still. Can’t you ever be comfortable–and unimportant?”
“No.” Harry turned away. “I have to go think about trains now. Excuse me.”
***
“Kill the spare,” whispered a hazy voice out of the darkness, and Harry heard “AVADA KEDAVRA,” and he saw a flash of green light, and Cedric was dead.
“A pity,” Harry said. “He would have made quite a fine architect, had he lived.”
“Quiet, boy!” Voldemort hissed. “I have you now.” He turned to face his followers, who were not being recompensed financially according to their service, which was ridiculous. “You know of course, that they have called this boy my downfall? You all know that on the night I lost my powers and my body, I tried to kill him. His mother died in the attempt to save him — and unwittingly provided him with a protection I admit I had not foreseen… I could not touch the boy. His mother left upon him the traces of her sacrifice… This is old magic, I should have remembered it, I was foolish to overlook it… but no matter. I can touch him now.”
Harry laughed.
“How dare you laugh at your death, you impertinent boy,” Voldemort snarled.
“My mother’s death was unnecessary,” Harry said. “It is not because she refused to honor her own life that you cannot touch me. It is because I have self-respect.”
“Impossible!” Voldemort cried. He shot all sorts of magic at Harry, but it didn’t work.
“Self-respect is something that can’t be killed. The worst thing is to kill a man’s pretense at it.” Harry turned to Voldemort’s followers. “You are fools — mediocre fools — because you work not for money but for the approval of others, for the approval of another man.”
“And what of that man?” Voldemort asked dangerously. “What do you think of me, Potter?”
“But I don’t think of you,” Harry said. He Disapparated back to Hogsmeade. “I only think about trains.”
He ordered another fire-whiskey and thought about trains.
Tags: ayn rand, books, fun with objectivism, harry potter, hermione stop doing their goddamn homework
I, too, only think about trains.
“…like some sort of sexually compelling locomotive.”
Picture scary-sex Harry face from when he came out of the Horocrux and made out with Hermione smashed onto the front of the Hogwarts Express, all Thomas the Tank Engine style. Yeah.
The thought of Cedric Diggory, Architect, will delight me to the end of my days.
Thanks to the movies, the follow up to that thought is Edward Cullen, Architect.
[I have never read or watched Twilight.]
Cullen & Mosby Archictecture, LLC
*shudder*
can a building contain so much undeserved self-congratulation
i fear for the integrity of space-time
ohgodnooooo
Randian Harry is coming off as pretty Asperger’s-y to me. I mean that as a compliment.
“He was born without the ability to consider others.” – Ayn Rand on Howard Roark
But a lot of recent work on cognitive psychology, IMHO, is really establishing Rand as a true visionary genius:
“Their idea is that some people are more strongly influenced by additional information than others who are confident in their own opinion. So identifying these more strongly influenced people and separating them from the independent thinkers creates two different groups. The group of independent thinkers is then more likely to give a wise estimate. Or put another way, ignore the wisdom of the crowd in favor of the wisdom of the confident.”
http://www.technologyreview.com/view/528941/forge…
You know, come to think of it, it IS pretty ridiculous that Voldemort’s followers weren’t financially recompensed for their services. Think of all the money they could’ve been making selling wands or magic candy or trains, instead of running all over the place killing people.
Most of them were already rich, and probably careless about financial rewards the way only the inheritors of vast magical estates can be.
“post-economic”
Ehhh, I don’t know. Not being murdered seems like pretty great compensation to me.
They were expecting to be rewarded with power in the new wizarding order, which is more or less as good as money.
It’s kind of like working for a startup where you get a lot of stock options.
“I love my job, but the hours are murder!”
I’m not really sure why but the fact that Harry snacks on a simple dish of plums made me laugh the most
I would like to read more about drunk Randian Harry yelling at the bathroom mirror about being an individual
Objectivist Harry Potter is really sexy, and I am in no way joking.
Seriously, this is likely the hottest thing I’ll read all week.
Speaking of hotter than hell, any mention of Ayn Rand makes me think of Patricia Neal and Gary Cooper in “The Fountainhead,” which in turn makes me think of Gary Cooper and Lupe Velez. Anne Helen Petersen tells a tale for all tastes here:
http://thehairpin.com/2012/06/scandals-of-classic…
This fact explains some of my most regrettable sexual decisions.
So Nicole thinks Objectivist Harry Potter is really sexy, and Mallory wants men to write to her about their failures.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4F4qzPbcFiA
Okay, if you are of this opinion you seriously should in fact read Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality.
nope not gonna do that
GOOD LIFE CHOICE. AVOID IT AT ALL COSTS.
I’m still mad. My life would have been objectively better had I never started reading it.
It’s not healthy to be this irritated with a [stupid] stranger.
I’m just not sure Madam Rosmerta needed any convincing to pour Harry a drink, no one ever seemed to hesitate to get underaged wizards boozed up. Remember old Slughorn offering Harry and Ron glasses of meade in his private office? And remember how Hermione says that butterbeer ‘isn’t very strong’ when Winky is getting sauced on it? Well clearly it has SOME strength to it, and all the kids are downing it like mother’s milk any second they get the chance! Point being, I think Ayn would already approve of the lax attitude to alcohol evident in the magical world.
He would have made a fine architect! Dead.
“youthful drinking is rightly governed by the laws of common sense and natural consequences.”
I didn’t know Objectivists were into getting drunk and puking into the gutter, but it makes a lot of sense now that I think about it.
The only unrealistic part of this is that Harry says “please” when ordering his fire whiskey.
“I have to go think about trains now. Excuse me.”
Used this on a coworker who doesn’t read (or likely even know about) The Toast (much to her detriment). Now she will go home wondering what it is about trains that occupies me so.
Thank you.
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire-Whiskey
There are people like this out there right now. Ew.
So basically, Randian Harry is Snape – at least the Snape of fanfiction.
They do both have the austere, imperious thing going on. But fanon!Snape is filled to the brim with angst and self-loathing!
“My present is the truth” – Perfect save for the next birthday I forget
If only he would think about trains… with me
how much for a ticket
Whatever it's worth. Plus like 40% cuz fire whiskey ain't cheap. And preferably paid for in gold you've earned through your own labor.
GOOD LIFE CHOICE. AVOID IT AT ALL COSTS.
Oh wow, flashbacks to the three weeks when I thought objectivism was awesome. And yeah, its amazing how much I remember after a decade, but yeah, there are a bunch of scenes that sound just like the Fountainhead.
I am a train therefore I am of highest value in the free market.