Sorry, But We Are Not Accepting Criticism At This Time

judgeThank you for attempting to contact us with your criticism. Your criticism is a valued part of the creative process here. Unfortunately, we are currently closed to criticism, with no plans to reopen to criticism anytime in the immediate future.

We are closed to both online and in-person criticisms. Please note that calls about the status of your pending criticism will not be answered.

Thank you for your interest in providing us with criticism; we regret being unable to accept it at this or any other time. It is our fondest and best wish that your criticism will find the best possible home elsewhere. We sincerely wish you the best of luck with your criticism.

We are not currently accepting criticisms from your region. We are not able to accept unsolicited criticism due to staff workflow, and will be returning any criticism unopened and unreviewed. We cannot accommodate any drop-ins or phone calls about the status of your particular criticism. Thank you for your patience during this time. We apologize for any inconvenience.

We regret to announce that we cannot keep any of your criticism on file should we become available to criticism again in the future. Unfortunately, we have no way of knowing when or if we will begin accepting criticism again. We are currently unable to answer any questions about our future availability for criticism.

Thanks so much for your criticism! If you are receiving this message, it is because we are closed to any and all incoming criticism and cannot accommodate yours at this time. Please consider sending your criticism elsewhere.

Tags: , ,

49 Comments

  1. spoboebot3000 +53

    Love you. Love this. Just read the Link Roundup with the little gem from a little creature who will not survive the Misandrist Revolution. Carry on, Mallory and Nicole. Carry on.

  2. winterbymorning +29

    I will endeavour to memorize this post, that I may repeat selected excerpts during my employee performance evaluation next month.

  3. katiemcgillicuddy +135

    BUT I JUST WANTED TO EXPLAIN TO YOU THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN NATURE AND MISOGYNY, WHY WON’T YOU LET ME HELP YOU UNDERSTAND

  4. renjender +42

    Would it be possible to make a tattoo out of this? I’d be willing to wear backless outfits for the rest of my life to let folks know the deal.

  5. literaltrousersnake +54

    The deleted comments section howls for blood, teeth gnashing at its restraints in the ice-storm by Satan’s head, but it cannot be heard because we are not accepting applications for devil’s advocate at this time, which has been clearly marked as “too late.”

  6. bibliobotic +40

    UHHHHH is it okay if I print this out on a small, tasteful piece of card stock, to whip from my pocket and present to my Weird Neighbor next time he starts lecturing me about my dog??? I know Scandyhoovian will want a copy as well.

  7. Sean_Sullivan +79

    Alternate venues for your criticism include:

    -The grunting stranger seated on the next bar stool
    -The head on your beer
    -The bottom of the glass
    -A mental health professional with a higher-than-median hourly rate
    -A faceless construct in a lucid dream
    -Dr. Madden, from the first chapter of George Gissing’s The Odd Women
    -A chat-bot designed to sell pagers
    -An immortal being of unbounded patience
    -A brick wall
    -A lake, after jumping into it
    -Your own face

  8. miprisci +73

    Well, what am I supposed to do? You won’t answer my comments, you change your email. I’m not gonna be ignored, Mallory!

    1. donkeywork +23

      Based on this movie and her vocal performance as Homer Simpson’s mother, my late father long campaigned for Glenn Close to become President, including during many non-election years.

  9. CMS +30

    Love this so much. I had a pretty terrible experience on another site, a ways back, and honestly all I said was I liked the essay or whatever (it was about Brooklyn or something) and people were mad that I made the comment, maybe it wasn’t smart enough? I guess what I am trying to say (in my un-smart way!) is that I love what you do and that you provide a nice place to chatter with fellow like minded friends.

    All the bravas to you.

  10. jtradke +29

    I don’t like this piece at all and here’s the list of reasons whTRANSMISSION TERMINATED ERROR CODE 0xA782F1 OOPSY-DAISY

  11. cee +73

    M: The Toast seems to be down
    Or just way slow
    me: hm!
    not for me
    M: Hmmm
    me: it’s because you’re a man

  12. ectocool +63

    But how am I being sexist? I didn’t even BRING up sexism, YOU did! ThAt MaKeS yOu tHe SeXiSt oNe!!!

      1. maccrocodile +18

        You might as well try to pay me in Bitcoin or lire. Sorry, our accounting software just isn’t set up to accept sass today.

  13. Mims_ +47

    I spent TIME and ENERGY on that comment and that is legally MONEY DOLLARS GUARANTEED PUBLICATION on the website and article of my choosing, and I choose YOUR website and I WILL NOT BE DENIED. Free speech.

  14. Goomaly +20

    You guys, I’ve had this site blocked all week so I could get some god damn work done. I have missed you so much.

  15. Heather S.

    Based on this movie and her vocal performance as Homer Simpson's mother, my late father long campaigned for Glenn Close to become President, including during many non-election years.

  16. Janet Eve Josselyn +7

    Despite Its Evident Merit
    Submission Guidelines for Rejections from The New Yorker

    Dear New Yorker Editors:

    Thank you for submitting your recent rejection of our latest submission. Unfortunately, the rejection isn’t right for us at this time, despite its evident merit.

    Before submitting a rejection in the future, you might want to familiarize yourself with our Submission Guidelines for rejections:

    1.There are only so many chuckles you can get out of making fun of conservative white men who work and have female wives. Open the humor up a little, please. Sometimes it’s actually funny to make sport of people who look or act odd. People who go all crazy-ass on people who eat meat can be really funny.

    2.Are all of the published authors of your journal related? We are not suggesting incest-style “related,” but we are suggesting “old boys club, wink-wink, nod-nod, not-if-you-are-a-girl-writer related.” Okay, just had to play the gender card. You guys are liberals, right?

    3.Evident merit comes in many sizes. Despite its evident merit, a rejection should evidence sufficient merit or it will not be right for us at this time.

    Thank you for allowing us to consider your rejection.

    Best regards,

    Rejected Writers Everywhere