
I am writing to you to share some vital information that has only become available to me in the last couple of years, since I became a parent.
Before that, I was subjected to the same saccharine clichés from parents that you are undoubtedly hearing over and over again. You’re probably being told, like I was, that you never really love until you become a parent. You’re probably hearing a lot about how no love can compare to the love a mother has for her child. Parents might be telling you that you’ll never ever EVER understand what real love feels like unless you become a parent yourself.
Well, now that I’ve crossed over from “nonparent” to “parent,” and with apologies to my fellow parents, I want to deliver this important message: You pretty much get it.
I always felt like the idea that mothers and fathers are the only people that get love was bullshit, but I never had standing to argue with any of them until my son was born. Now that I’ve been on both sides of the fence, I’m very happy to report that things are just as I’d assumed they would be. That love is love, wherever you’re standing.
The love a mother has for her child is unique, that much is true. It would be stupid to say it isn’t. But isn’t every kind of love unique? The love I have for my sisters is different than my love for my husband. The way I love my parents is not the same way I love my best friend. I don’t have any brothers or cats or parakeets, but I would guess that those relationships come with their own special flavors of love as well.
But you don’t hear parakeet owners running around telling non-parakeet owners that they will have no idea what real love feels like until they get a parakeet.
I loved plenty of people before my son was born and I don’t feel that that love has faded or diminished at all since I became a mom. My love for my family and friends is fierce and loyal and wild and real and I will seriously side-eye anyone who tries to tell me otherwise.
I’m hoping you feel the same way. And I hope you don’t really need me to tell you that the love you’re experiencing as a childfree person is real and significant and big. I hope you won’t let any of those rogue, self-righteous parents drag you into competing in the love Olympics.
The truth is, my being a mother doesn’t make me any better at or more capable of love than any other feeling person. My son is not some mythical creature that broke my stony heart wide open. He’s not this ray of light that magically gave my pathetic life meaning or transformed me into some amazing new person with extra overhead room in the cardiac area.
My kid is just another person in my life that I love. Like a sister, like a grandfather, like a best friend.
You know what that’s like. I know you do. Don’t let anyone tell you you don’t.
Aubrey Hirsch is the author of Why We Never Talk About Sugar. Her work has appeared in The New York Times, The Rumpus, Brain, Child Magazine and elsewhere. Follow her on Twitter: @aubreyhirsch.
Forgot password?
Close message
Subscribe to this blog post's comments through...
Subscribe via email
SubscribeComments (89)
Sort by: Date Rating Last Activity
urspostrophe 122p · 537 weeks ago
projectbeks 119p · 537 weeks ago
Seriously, though, I want to put a poster of this up on every street corner. As a mom (and a feeling human being first and foremost, dammit), thank you.
Ethylbenzene 119p · 537 weeks ago
Jenna/TheWordCellar · 537 weeks ago
GreenGrasses 121p · 537 weeks ago
daisicles 95p · 537 weeks ago
But I like having the confirmation.
whizzdumb 100p · 537 weeks ago
turanga_leela 121p · 537 weeks ago
Genny_ 95p · 537 weeks ago
Rianne 108p · 537 weeks ago
Parents are not mythical beings beyond the comprehension of us lowly childless mortals.
osutein 136p · 537 weeks ago
bitzyboozer 119p · 537 weeks ago
lilsebastian01 151p · 537 weeks ago
chickpeas · 537 weeks ago
I stopped listening to/hanging out with people who say this shit, so haven't heard these horrible cliches in quite some time... but thank you for writing this all the same. It's really surprising to me, the number of people who feel okay about declaring that they were unloving monsters for a huge chunk of their lives! Like... maybe I am not the problem here, you know? I love plenty of people (and furry creatures, too), always have.
Nyasha Junior · 537 weeks ago
literaltrousersnake · 537 weeks ago
Ophelia · 537 weeks ago
OliviaPJones 108p · 537 weeks ago
Edit: Of course, I should acknowledge that I live in the Bay Area and pretty much all the parents I know are super cool folks who still wanna hang out, just with their kid, earlier in the evening, and not as long. What I do believe is that super-absorbed people stay super-absorbed regardless of whether or not they have children, and people that don't suck tend to stay that way.
figtreecooking 114p · 537 weeks ago
I also think it would be better if our cultural dialogue focused more on the transformative stuff (and talked more about the fact that you're not just getting a cute newborn but a person who goes through many stages of life), but of course selling the love angle is more appealing.
JAG · 537 weeks ago
hallie l. · 537 weeks ago
SERIOUSLY.
Love, an infertile-five-years-running-woman who is SICK TO DEATH of hearing she has no love and no clue and her empty womb represents her total emptiness.
msk · 537 weeks ago
nomadpoet 1p · 537 weeks ago
Elle_Dee 55p · 537 weeks ago
Jack Wilson · 537 weeks ago
They don't just say it to pat themselves on the back (although smug quotes on Facebook are never a good idea). I'm one of them. The whole way that I view the world, the way that I see other people, has completely changed because I have children. And I don't see how my relationship with my wife, with my own parents, could ever reach the same stage if I never had children.
I understand the irritation with anyone telling you what you can and can't understand in your own life, based on their life. But by the same token, I don't think this one author's assessment is the definitive statement on whether having children can be drastically life-altering and fundamentally changes your view of the world.
And that fact doesn't have to diminish the experience of anyone else who may have their own personal battle scars from a lifelong commitment. I guess it's all in the delivery!
simoneblatt 106p · 537 weeks ago
Sorry to be a dissenter on this thread of people patting themselves on the back about what chumps and liars parents are. Yes, parents are chumps and sometimes they lie. Yes, probably plenty of people don't have the same experience becoming a parent that I did. But to claim all parents are full of shit making claims about what being a parent is like for them is ridiculous. For me personally, becoming a mother unlocked a huge and humbling mass of new personality traits that I'm still trying to figure out, 20 months in.
Sooooo if you were planning on having a kid to experience this special love all your facebook friends are shouting about but this article convinced you not to, maybe reconsider? I don't know.
Katie · 537 weeks ago
Jsquib · 537 weeks ago
Jsquib · 537 weeks ago
I really hate the attitude of anyone that is "You don't know anything about ______ until you've [something the speaker has done that the other person hasn't]." It's condescending and obnoxious, and while it's certainly not limited to parents, it seems to be particularly visible there. "You think you're tired because you ran a marathon/defended your thesis/work three jobs? Ha! You don't know what it means to be tired until you have kids!" "You don't REALLY understand love until you have kids!"
plasticcup 47p · 537 weeks ago
I am so sick of the "war" between parents and the childfree. It's true, those of us without children do not know what it’s like to love a child in the specific way a mother or father does. But…..there’s nothing wrong with that. While some of us dislike children, there are quite a few of us who love kids—we just don’t want to raise any of our own. We choose to live a lifestyle different than yours, not because we hate you, or look down upon you, but because we have no great longing for offspring and we have many goals we wish to achieve that would be sidelined by having children. This does not make us evil or selfish or heartless, unfeeling monsters; on the contrary, childfree people often have more time and resources to give to those in need than parents do, because we do not have the very real and very large expense of children weighing us down. Many childfree people are even the lifeboats for parents who fall on hard times or are irresponsible with their money and cannot afford to give their children everything they need. Parents would not have access to such generosity if everyone had their own kids to pay for. I think it’s a blessing that we are allowed to choose which path we take.
Parents: do not see us as the enemy. We may or may not want anything to do with your children, but that is our right as we were not the ones who had any say in their creation. For those of us like me, we are thrilled that you were able to realize your dream of having a baby, and we wish you all the best. We will be there to witness your child’s growth into adulthood and may even take an active, loving role in helping him or her get there. But do not offer us fake pity for not knowing “the love of a child like a parent does.” We don’t want it, we aren’t missing it, and we feel whole loving our friends, families, partners, pets, and ourselves. We too have families. They’re just smaller than yours.
tundra33 · 537 weeks ago
Okay, but that didn't happen. What she said is that parents who use their experiences to tell other people what parenthood would be like for *them* are full of shit. What she said is not that a parent is full of shit who says "Having a child is transformative for me." What she said is that a parent is full of shit who says to a person without children, "Having a child would be transformative for *you* in this particular way," a/k/a "*you* do not understand real love." Nobody is questioning a parent who wants to say, "I never really understood love until I had my child." This is addressed to people who assume that experience to be universal and use it as a way to consider themselves automatically more emotionally evolved and sophisticated than people without children. And unfortunately, yes, that is a pretty common thing to hear from parents.
Incidentally, oh my God, if you are considering having children in response to anything that ANYONE says about being a parent on Facebook, please don't. That is bone-chilling.
Saffah · 537 weeks ago
SophieEvans · 537 weeks ago
cheekypinky 85p · 537 weeks ago
Desiree · 536 weeks ago
radkitten 0p · 536 weeks ago
madge · 536 weeks ago
lambethgal09 0p · 536 weeks ago
mandawritesthings 0p · 534 weeks ago
Gwen · 534 weeks ago
I want to run and tell my husband "YOU will never know RELIEF until you read this article as a childless stepmom." But that's a little foul-played...
Thanks again for such a supportive read!
Melissa · 533 weeks ago
in rainbows · 523 weeks ago
I'm a live and let live type; unfortunately I've now found out that my husband's family most definitely aren't that type since they've realised we will be remaining child free. From parents and siblings in law that I thought accepted us as we were and who I felt very close to (I've known them for 16 years), we have become outcasts, almost entirely isolated from family events. When we do meet up, the pitying and sometimes even contemptuous looks and comments are so hard to bear that we are now reluctant to meet, making the situation worse.
I like children a lot; I've been a social worker in a children's home for 11 years, a good, committed practitioner. But I made a tough decision due to several factors, that I wouldn't have my own, and I've done my grieving. I never believed that my in law family would have acted like this and it really hurts, and has affected my mental health. I can only appeal to those who give either parents or the child free/less a hard time, there's no war here; don't judge until you have walked a mile in someone else's shoes.
Post a new comment
Comment as a Guest, or login:
Comments by IntenseDebate
Reply as a Guest, or login: