Every New England Novel Ever

winterPreviously: Every Irish novel ever.

1. A Foreboding Trip To The Old Manse

2. Exchanging Words At The Maple-Tapping Party

3. Everyone Refused To Come Downstairs

4. No One Redecorates The Violet Room

5. Children Who Speak Out Of Turn Will Have No Maple Candy At Christmas-Tide

6. Don’t Sit In That Chair, Boy; Your Mother Sat In That Chair Once And Look Where It Got Her

7. This Close Childhood Friendship Is No Longer Appropriate For Reasons We Must Never Discuss

8. Brisk Ten-Mile Walks Are The Only Medicine Or Therapy This Family Needs

9. The Cod Have Returned

10. Not Everything In Yon Churchyard Is Asleep

11. The Mills Have Closed And Taken Our Dream Of Restoring The Family Honor With Them

12. Going Outdoors: A Cure For All Social Ills

13. Graham Crackers Are Better Than Marital Relations

14. The Bluestockings Arrive For Tea

15. Barely-Audible Gossip During The Sherry Hour

16. The Salem Witch Trials Aren’t As Over As You Might Think

17. An Outsider Is Rebuffed

18. He Made His Money In Trade

19. Her Welcome, Like The Weather, Grew Chilly

20. The Friendly Baseball Game That Changed Everything

21. A Misunderstood Joke In Latin

22. Death At Boarding School

23. We Never Speak Of The Accident

24. Sleighing Is Such Fun

25. Directions Are Given In A Sinister Fashion

Tags: , ,

97 Comments

  1. ladyimogen +54

    “12. Going Outdoors: A Cure For All Social Ills” is a lesson I learned early and well, and will LIVE MY LIFE BY.

  2. ppyajunebug +129

    If It Was Good Enough For Your Puritan Ancestors, It’s Good Enough For You.

    Relatedly:

    Having Fun Is Still Sinful, How Dare You.

  3. ladyimogen +113

    Hard Work is Virtuous and Satisfying

    Dying Young is a Sign of Excellent Moral Fiber

  4. thewhelk +78

    Emotions: Let’s not have them.

    The Hughly Granulated Socio-Economic Signaling of your docksiders

    1. TheasyPeasy +21

      I live Outside of New England now, but my NE friend and I have a consistent policy that the feelings must be destroyed. The further we get from NE the more we have feelings. It is AWFUL.

    2. Holly_Kat +12

      It reminds me of my favorite MST3K short: A Date With Your Family, in which Crow explains to us that “emotions are for ethnic people.”

      1. thewhelk +14

        “Nothing distracts more from the charm of a conversation …..then having a personality.”

        “I had a feeling today father” “Well stop it.”

        “A violent argument erupts over whose day was more pleasant.”

        That’s my favorite. That and Century 21 Calling

  5. literaltrousersnake +24

    SUCK IT, NEW ENGLAND, WITH YOUR COD THAT RETURN TO YOU. ::furious waving of Canada/Maritime flags::

    1. merveille +26

      OMG, yes. My mother grew up in a town where the major conflict was the Congregationalists, Methodists, and Presbyterians were united by their traditional enemy, French Canadian Catholics.

      1. CaroWR +36

        In the 19th century my home town had three Congregational churches and two Episcopalian churches (and three other churches) despite having a population of around 950 people because the people with shipping money couldn’t deal with going to the same church as the people who worked in the piano factory.

        There’s also a series of incredibly dry books about notable houses by the historical society (which is basically one ornery guy), including the first house to be occupied by an ITALIAN, who I’m sure everyone thought had some nerve.

        1. kilks401 +23

          3 catholic churches in my 20 minustes north of Boston town, god forbid the Italians, Irish, and Polish went to the same church.

          1. CaroWR +20

            Of course!

            My grandmother grew up in Stamford, CT and her Irish best friend maintains that she’s not racist because she’s friends with my Italian grandmother.

            She is, in fact, super racist and antisemitic and probably anti-Muslim. My grandfather apparently banned her from the house for about ten years for saying something antisemitic about my mother, but sadly I wasn’t born yet and couldn’t benefit from her absence.

  6. irishbreakfasttime +74

    Really, Can You Blame Us For The Unpleasantness, We Are So Very Cold And Isolated

    I Have Taken To My Bed

    Feh, New Yorkers!

  7. Sean_Sullivan +74

    This (plus yesterday’s Ethan Frome article) brings to mind a MetaFilter comment:

    The Scarlet Letter helped prepare the barren soil, but New England was killed off as a setting for Romance by Ethan Frome, the single drabbest and most depressing love story in human history. For those with eyes to see the Romantic terrain, New England is a lunar crater extending from Delaware to Nova Scotia, with Ethan Frome at ground zero. (“Starkfield,” forsooth.) Such is Ethan Frome’s anti-romantic power that it extends backwards fifty years from its publication date; and forward indefinitely. No, sorry, the closest thing to gothic romance from New England is Ahab and that whale.

  8. Blanche de Shambles +21

    The Cod Have Returned

    That one’s “The Shadow over Innsmouth,” isn’t it?

      1. sdpowell1 +16

        So. Much. Whaling.

        *patiently waits for that Thor on a Whaling Ship movie to be released*

  9. Natalie +34

    “Her Welcome, Like The Weather, Grew Chilly”

    Pretty sure that’s the title for my autobiography.

    1. leslieellenjones +15

      Her Welcome, Like the Weather, Changed Every Fifteen Minutes (the Vermont version, at any rate).

  10. latenac +30

    First, every novel? I believe you mean every family/town in real life.

    Second, it’s obvious to me that every New England novel needs a Flora Poste to come in and clean house.

  11. ArsenioB_Ham +32

    Avoid Human Contact At All Costs

    ETA: This is also the name of my self-help book #PersonalBrand

  12. thewhelk +53

    Let’s Do And Wear Things That Ralph Lauren Will Endlessly Fetishize But Never Really *Understand*

  13. typewriterandgramophone +28

    A gentle person dies an agonizing, yet edifying death.

    And all those rich old families made their money in trade, didn’t they? Whether the China trade or the whale oil trade or…that OTHER trade we don’t speak of.

      1. deleted182847 +9

        Is it also New England or just England where a young man could find himself a situation at the haberdasher’s and attempt to woo the proprietor’s daughter?

        1. LeftyLibrarian +7

          You win all the points I have to give for that 1776 reference. I bow down to you.

    1. Nimona +31

      Where I come from (Massachusetts) most people did make their MONEY in trade, but your social standing still came from having fancy ancestors. If you had money but un-fancy ancestors you were still not cool, and if you had fancy ancestors but no money… well, see every New England novel ever written.

  14. jsmccloud +47

    This Small Town Has Dark Secrets, And We Do Not Speak of Them, Especially When People Die

  15. typewriterandgramophone +18

    A repressed lesbian finds new purpose in intellectual pursuits and social justice work. The right woman for her is out there somewhere and what better way to find her?

      1. typewriterandgramophone +5

        “The Bostonians” also (kind of) “Work” by Louisa May Alcott.

        (I want Olive Chancellor to be happy. So, so much.)

  16. hysterietta +39

    8. Brisk Ten-Mile Walks Are The Only Medicine Or Therapy This Family Needs

    Ha-ha!

    *weeps*

    1. Nausikaa +11

      That is my family. I didn’t realize we were from New England, but now I know.

      We also run. And swim. But the overall theme of “What anti-depressants we don’t need anti-depressants we just need to do some more miles on the ol’ elliptical and take the dog up the hill” still holds true.

      1. Unreadaethel +7

        Or, in the case of a friend of mine and his distressing family, “let’s just get all of the graduate degrees, preferably at once.” There’s just so much WASPy disfunction.

    1. stregastrigoi +6

      This is the derby team I need to join with my awesome hypothetical derby name: Lady Shatterknees

  17. writingortyping +55

    Let’s Play a Fun Game: It’s Called Pilgrim’s Progress

    Inchoate Yearning Crosses Harvard Yard

    It’s Snowing. Again.

    1. Nausikaa +16

      “Inchoate Yearning Crosses Harvard Yard” would also make a good Vampire Weekend song.

  18. megalesias +41

    He Shot His Hand Off With A Harpoon And Now His Marriage Is Unhappy
    (aka my 3-greats-grandfather! good times)

    also, can we have a subsection for Crime Novel Mob Bosses Who Totally Aren’t Whitey Bulger, Guys.

    1. megalesias +29

      other literary features from my family history:

      Everyone Knows Her Cousin Is The Town Drunk, But We Don’t Talk About It

      and

      If You Marry A Catholic, Your Kids Won’t Be Masons

  19. zolora +54

    Someone Falls Through The Ice On The Skating Pond

    The Ship Is Lost Forever

    Farming: A Noble Yet Futile Profession

    At Least We Have Christmas, Christmas Is Pretty Great

    The Lighthouse Is A Metaphor

    1. beagee +16

      “The Lighthouse is a Metaphor” also generally comes with the subheading “And Also Very Haunted.”

      Having grown up in an actual museum in New England I can tell you, the lighthouse is always the most haunted place. Even people who don’t talk about/believe in ghosts will nod knowingly when the haunted-ness of the lighthouse is mentioned.

  20. typewriterandgramophone +20

    There’s a decent old gentleman, still wearing his uncle’s old topcoat, whose life is as clean as his diction. Much as you wish to win his approval, you never will. You have the right name and the right suspenders but you don’t have the fine old spirit of the fine old days, though your friend, young Lowenstein, does. One day after Lowenstein has done some particularly fine work, the decent old gentleman lets his hand rest, very briefly, on young Lowenstein’s shoulder. You feel your soul scrunch up with envy.

      1. Unreadaethel +7

        You begin to spread unwholesome rumors about the way in which young Lowenstein’s father got his place in the world, by off-handedly mentioning it to the parson’s wife, then swearing her to absolute secrecy.

  21. livingindialogue +4

    Now you’ve made me eager to reread the Moosepath League books, set in Maine, but decidedly not like that. I haven’t yet read the final one, and I do so need to know what happens to Sundry Moss and the rest of his oh-so-eccentric friends.

  22. peace92 +31

    The Ocean Is Gray And We Are All Doomed

    We Will Keep Our Family Secrets Until After The Wedding

    My L.L. Bean Parka Is Older Than Yours

  23. stephaniebernhard +7

    Papa got by just fine without a television set

    The old stone wall is a metaphor

    I saw a Kennedy once

  24. Florida Girl

    I too had oranges in my Christmas stocking along with walnuts. If the candy canes (perhaps one or two) were not displayed at the top of the stocking, I might not have known Santa had paid us a visit. We were poor and, I think, we knew it. Have fun with memories.

  25. halloweenjack64 +3

    This Close Childhood Friendship Is No Longer Appropriate For Reasons We Must Never Discuss

    (Not That We Need To, After All, They Didn’t Call Them “Boston Marriages” For Nothing)

  26. Halloween Jack

    This Close Childhood Friendship Is No Longer Appropriate For Reasons We Must Never Discuss

    (Not That We Need To, After All, They Didn't Call Them "Boston Marriages" For Nothing)

  27. halloweenjack64 +8

    Also, special Stephen King division: Have I Told You About This Creepy Little Town I Used To Live In? I Did? Well, Have I Written The Sequel Yet?

  28. Halloween Jack

    Also, special Stephen King division: Have I Told You About This Creepy Little Town I Used To Live In? I Did? Well, Have I Written The Sequel Yet?

  29. Hadrosaur +1

    The Young Man New In Town Looks Just Like His Ancestor/Nobody Talks About The Night We Drove Out The Old Wizard

  30. Hadrosaur82

    The Young Man New In Town Looks Just Like His Ancestor/Nobody Talks About The Night We Drove Out The Old Wizard